Tested 31 times by independent publications, the Michelin Pilot Sport 4 S has taken 13 test wins with an average finish of 2nd. Its strongest discipline is Dry Braking, beating 75% of the field across 28 tests; its weakest is Subj. Wet Handling, at 44% across 10 tests.
31Independent tests
13Test wins
24Podium finishes
2ndAverage finish
78%Field beaten on average
9Publications
Advertisement
31 tests, 2017 to 2026
Share of the field beaten in each test, oldest to newest. Hover or tap a point for the test.
The Michelin Pilot Sport 4 S is Michelin's max performance summer tire and it behaves like one. It is the strongest all round wet performer in this range and gives up surprisingly little to the track tires in a straight line stop, while remaining an easy, communicative tire to drive fast. If you want the widest usable performance envelope on a road car that also sees dry track work, this is where the range peaks.
Where the Michelin Pilot Sport 4 S finished in each measured discipline, across every test that measured it against at least two other tires. Field beaten is the share of the other tires it outranked in that measurement.
Record by discipline
Discipline
Tests
Avg finish
Field beaten
Firsts
Dry
Dry Braking Strong
28
P2.5 of 8
75%
7
Dry Handling
29
P2.9 of 7.9
71%
7
Dry Circle
1
P2 of 10
89%
-
Subj. Dry Handling
12
P2.8 of 7.5
74%
3
Subj. Road Score
2
P3 of 9.5
78%
1
Wet
Wet Braking
28
P2.9 of 8
74%
9
Wet Handling
27
P4.2 of 8.1
56%
3
Subj. Wet Handling Weak
10
P4.9 of 8
44%
-
Wet Circle
8
P3.8 of 8.5
66%
2
Straight Aqua
24
P4 of 8.4
55%
3
Curved Aquaplaning
11
P4.6 of 8.8
51%
2
Snow
Snow Braking
1
P3 of 3
0%
-
Snow Traction
1
P3 of 3
0%
-
Snow Handling
1
P3 of 3
0%
-
Comfort
Subj. Comfort
10
P2.5 of 7.4
80%
4
Subj. Noise
1
P2 of 7
83%
-
Noise
21
P5 of 8.4
47%
1
Tire Weight
2
P2.5 of 9
80%
-
Value
Rolling Resistance
24
P3.6 of 8.4
66%
3
Head-to-head record
Overall finishing position against the tires that have most often shared a test with the Michelin Pilot Sport 4 S. Only tires tested alongside it at least three times are listed.
Across 32 independent tests, the Michelin Pilot Sport 4 S shows an unusually consistent “near-the-top” profile (average overall position 2.1) built around elite dry performance and a confidence-inspiring, refined road demeanour. It is frequently right on the pace for outright circuit-style metrics (e.g. 1st of 7 in dry handling, 2024 Auto Bild Sports Cars; 1st of 9 in dry handling, 2021 Auto Bild UUHP; 1st of 7 in dry handling, 2025 Auto Bild Sports Cars UUHP) while also scoring strongly in subjective steering/road use (e.g. 1st of 9 for road score, 2026 evo test; “perfectly tuned steering feel”, 2025 Auto Bild Sports Cars UUHP). Awards back this up, including three “Highly recommended” results (notably 2022 Tire Reviews UUHP and 2021 Tire Reviews UHP, plus Auto Bild's Highly Recommended verdict in 2021).
The main pattern of exceptions is that wet performance is more variable than its dry pace: it can be class-leading in some wet braking/handling scenarios (e.g. 1st of 7 in wet braking, 2024 evo; 1st of 15 in wet braking, 2021 Auto Bild 19-inch; “most complete wet weather tire” within Michelin's own 2026 range test), but it also posts below-average wet braking/handling results in a number of more recent premium-field comparisons (e.g. 7th of 8 in wet braking, +11.6% from best, 2026 Auto Bild Sportscars; 8th of 10 in wet braking, +10.9%, 2025 Tire Rack). Testers also repeatedly flag cost and, depending on fitment, some limitations at/over the limit (understeer or a narrow wet window) plus occasional noise and efficiency penalties versus less aggressive categories.
Performance Strengths
Dry handlingStrongin 17 of 30 testsDetails
1st of 7 in dry handling, 2024 Auto Bild Sports Cars Summer Tire Test
1st of 9 in dry handling, 2021 Auto Bild UUHP Summer Tire Test (265/35 R20)
1st of 7 in dry handling, 2025 Auto Bild Sports Cars UUHP Tire Test (Lotus Emira)
Strong braking, great precision and very low sensitivity to load changes on a dry track - 2023 Sport Auto UHP Tire Test (2023)
Very short braking distances in the wet and dry, high levels of grip, very direct steering response and very high steering prevision in the dry, low rolling resistance - 2021 Sport Auto UHP Summer Tire Test (2021)
Steering feelStrongin 17 of 30 testsDetails
Tagged write-ups: Steering feel praised 17 times vs criticised 5 times (73% mention share, weighted verdict +0.64)
“Perfectly tuned steering feel and handling behavior”, 2025 Auto Bild Sports Cars UUHP Tire Test
“Superb steering connection, feel and linearity” on road route (1st of 9 road score), 2026 evo Summer Tire Test
Very short braking distances in the wet and dry, high levels of grip, very direct steering response and very high steering prevision in the dry, low rolling resistance - 2021 Sport Auto UHP Summer Tire Test (2021)
Excellent grip in the dry and wet, good aquaplaning resistance, low levels of noise, low rolling resistance - 2022 Tire Reviews UUHP Summer Tire Test (2022)
Performance Weaknesses
Value for moneyStrongin 1 of 30 testsDetails
“By far the most expensive tire tested... price-to-performance ratio doesn't add up”, 2026 Auto Bild Sportscars Summer Tire Test (5th of 8 overall)
“Most expensive tires on test”, 2020 Auto Bild UHP 19 inch Tire Test (1st of 10 overall)
“High Price” / “Very expensive” called out despite strong results, 2021 Auto Bild 19 inch & 2021 Auto Bild UUHP tests
Every tester write-up on the Michelin Pilot Sport 4 S (30 tests) and 154 owner reviews were tagged for the aspects they judge. Where both have spoken, this is how they line up.
Where owners and testers agree
AspectTestersOwners
Dry grip strength in 14 of 30 tests 73 praise, 7 criticise of 154 reviews · Read those reviews
Wet grip strength in 10 of 30 tests 66 praise, 3 criticise of 154 reviews · Read those reviews
Dry handling strength in 17 of 30 tests 40 praise, 3 criticise of 154 reviews · Read those reviews
Ride comfort strength in 11 of 30 tests 48 praise, 10 criticise of 154 reviews · Read those reviews
Road noise strength in 5 of 30 tests 38 praise, 14 criticise of 154 reviews · Read those reviews
Dry braking strength in 14 of 30 tests 14 praise, 1 criticise of 154 reviews · Read those reviews
Where they disagree
AspectTestersOwners
Sidewall stiffness strength in 1 of 30 tests 3 praise, 14 criticise of 154 reviews · Read those reviews
Every test, newest first 31
Strong = top two of the field in that measurement. Weak = bottom two.
No tests match these filters. Clear a filter to see more.
The Michelin Pilot Sport 4 S is Michelin's max performance summer tire and it behaves like one. It is the strongest all round wet performer in this range and gives up surprisingly little to the track tires in a straight line stop, while remaining an easy, communicative tire to drive fast. If you want the widest usable performance envelope on a road car that also sees dry track work, this is where the range peaks.
The Michelin Pilot Sport 4S is strong on dry roads, posting the second-fastest dry handling lap with good turn-in and controllability at the limit. It also leads the aquaplaning test on the front axle at 56.0 mph, but the rear floats much earlier at 51.8 mph - the largest front-to-rear imbalance in the test. Wet handling and wet braking are below average for this field. At roughly 1020 euros per set it is by far the most expensive tire tested, and the price-to-performance ratio doesn't add up.
Michelin Pilot Sport 4S claimed the overall test victory with 141 out of 170 points and a "very recommended" rating. It scored 68 out of 80 in wet safety - joint second-best alongside Linglong - and 53 out of 60 in dry safety, placing it among the top tier on both surfaces. It was one of four tires sharing the best dry handling marks, praised for good cornering stability, precise steering, and a safe, controllable character. On the wet handling course it was named among the top three, credited with good traction out of corners. Its only relative weakness was economy at 20 out of 30, the joint lowest alongside Kumho. This well-rounded consistency across both wet and dry disciplines, with no category below the mid-pack, is what ultimately secured it the top position in a very tight field.
The Michelin Pilot Sport 4 S dropped from second in the previous test of this size to fifth here, though it finished just a fraction off fourth place. Around the wet lap it was well balanced with useful, exploitable rotation, and felt strong on the brakes. However, on turn-in it needed a moment to key into the surface before you could pour on the power and settle the car onto its rear for the exit. In the dry it was a similar story – a bit noisy, droning under load, but capable with good feel and decent precision. It didn't put a wheel wrong; it just lacked the brightness and sharp focus of the very best. Where the Michelin truly excelled was on the road route, where superb steering connection, feel and linearity helped it achieve the top ranking, along with low road noise and good rolling comfort. An accomplished all-rounder.
StrongSubj. Road ScoreStraight AquaRolling Resistance WeakDry Handling WinnerBridgestone Potenza Sport
The Pilot Sport 4 S finished first in the test with 97.5 points. Strongest on lap time, ride comfort and subjective dry handling, with the longer wet stop and third-place dry braking holding it back.
Still a strong, accurate-handling tire with solid dry pace and dependable grip, but no longer the clear class leader. It suffers from elevated noise levels and edginess at the limit, especially in the wet, where it trails the latest competition in both braking and lap times.
The Michelin Pilot Sport 4S was described as the "winner of hearts" due to its perfectly balanced steering and handling characteristics. With its perfectly tuned steering feel and handling behavior, the Michelin excels on dry surfaces, achieving the best time in dry handling tests and impressive short braking distances. Testers specifically highlighted its well-balanced behavior that made it a standout performer. On wet roads, it maintained harmonious dynamic qualities, though it showed some weakness in longitudinal aquaplaning conditions. Overall, the Pilot Sport 4S impressed with its exceptional precision and balanced performance.
StrongDry BrakingDry HandlingWet BrakingWet Circle WeakStraight Aqua WinnerContinental SportContact 7
Tire Reviews · 225/40 R18 Tested by Tire ReviewsHighly Rec.
The Michelin Pilot Sport 4S is another really well rounded tire, super safe and dynamic, especially sub limit where the steering is really nice. At the limit it still isn't quite the sportiest of the bunch, but if you're not going on track a lot, it's a really difficult tire to not recommend.
StrongSubj. Dry HandlingSubj. ComfortRolling Resistance WeakWet HandlingNoise WinnerPirelli P Zero PZ5
This tire demonstrated sporty, dynamic handling with stable lateral grip on both wet and dry surfaces. It offers direct steering response and good feedback to the driver. The Pilot Sport 4S needed about two meters more stopping distance than the Continental in wet braking tests and showed some limitations in the curved aquaplaning test.
The Michelin Pilot Sport 4S is a very good performer that excelled on dry surfaces with high cornering grip. The Michelin delivered slightly quicker lap times on the track than the Continental, but with a narrower performance window on wet surfaces. While it offered high lateral grip on wet roads, it had a relatively narrow performance window before grip suddenly broke away. The tire showed a tendency toward gentle understeer, making it predictable and safe even for less experienced drivers. One of the more expensive options in the test.
The Michelin Pilot Sport 4 S demonstrated significant improvements over its previous version, particularly in straight-line aquaplaning where it had traditionally struggled. The standout performance came in wet braking, where it jumped from third to first place. The tire felt secure and precise in wet conditions, ranking fourth in both subjective scores and lap times. It was especially impressive in high-speed wet driving, offering a fluid feel through transitions with bright and connected steering feedback. While not outstanding in all wet tests, it made up for this with strong dry performance and good refinement. The combination of strong wet performance, excellent dry handling, and the lowest rolling resistance in the test secured its second-place finish.
Tire Reviews · 255/35 R19 Tested by Tire ReviewsHighly Rec.
The Michelin Pilot Sport 4S continues to be a tire that does everything well, excelling in every test and having a range of abilities no tire can rival. The negative of the PS4S is the same as always, it has slightly slower steering and worse feedback than the best on test, but this does bring levels of refinement the sportier tires can't match.
Considering the Michelin Pilot Sport 4 S is the most road focused tire in this track test, it was very impressive. There is the usual 4S delay to the steering, especially compared to the SuperCar 3, and the steering is light and non communicative. However this would be the best tire in the wet, and offers road levels of comfort. Impressive all round ability.
WeakDry HandlingSubj. Dry Handling WinnerGoodyear Eagle F1 SuperCar 3R
Tire Reviews · 225/40 R18 Tested by Tire ReviewsHighly Rec.
The Michelin Pilot Sport 4S is an extremely rounded UUHP tire, offering the most complete blend of qualities. The trade off for all these qualities seems to be in dry handling, where it doesn't feel the most sporty of tires.
StrongDry BrakingStraight Aqua WeakRolling Resistance
The Pilot Sport 4 S was good in the wet and outstanding in the dry, setting the fastest dry lap time and topping our subjective ratings on track and on the road route, where it impressed with superb steering feel and feedback and ride comfort. A great tire that will improve the feel of your performance car.
The Pilot Sport 4 S bundled the test’s highest lateral grip and shortest stopping distance into the only sub-30-second lap time. That betters the next-fastest tire, Pirelli’s P Zero, by 0.5 second.
In driving, speed usually grows as confidence grows, and this Michelin exemplifies that idea. The Pilot Sport 4 S assures the driver with its tenacious grip, stellar lateral stiffness, and progressive at-the-limit behavior. It is easy and rewarding to drive aggressively, and it allows the driver to return to full throttle earlier than any other tire in this test.
Out in the real world, the Michelin demonstrated a subtle tendency to follow grooves in the road. Otherwise, the Pilot Sport 4 S is as docile in traffic as it is around a racetrack, never hammering down imperfections nor singing on the smooth stuff.
As with the Pilot Super Sport, Michelin is likely to be faced with so many automakers eager to fit the 4 S to their sports cars that it will turn customers away. Fortunately, you don’t need Michelin’s approval to fit your car with Pilot Sport 4 S tires.