Menu

Test source EVO

2014 EVO Max Performance Summer Tire Test

Overall test winnerContinental Sport Contact 5

Here at TireReviews we always get excited when EVO publish a tire test. Normally tire tests focus on raw numbers, dedicating pages to telling you which tire has 0.1% more grip, but forgetting to mention how the tires actually feel on the…

Tires tested
10
Tested size
225/45 R17

At a glance

Tire shortlist

10 Tires tested

Published finishing positions, with the strengths and considerations from this test. Owner reviews cover other sizes and driving conditions.

2nd

Pirelli P Zero

4th

Yokohama Advan Neova AD08

5th

Michelin Pilot Sport 3 PS3

6th

Vredestein Ultrac Vorti

7th

Toyo Proxes T1 Sport

8th

Hankook Ventus S1 evo2

9th

Dunlop Sport Maxx RT

10th

Bridgestone Potenza S001

Tire shortlist

Compare selected tires

2014 EVO Max Performance Summer Tire Test · 225/45 R17

Explore the complete results →

The full test

The evidence behind the verdict

Here at TireReviews we always get excited when EVO publish a tire test. Normally tire tests focus on raw numbers, dedicating pages to telling you which tire has 0.1% more grip, but forgetting to mention how the tires actually feel on the car.

Conversely EVO spend plenty of time, and dedicate 60% of the overall result, to subjective handling. With the difference in grip between the best tires on the market ever shrinking, explaining how the tires actually feel to use give people who enjoy driving a good reference point. This years test was carried out at the Bridgestone test track in Italy, on a VW Golf GTI wearing 225/45 R17 tires.

 

The top three

It's back to the top step for Continental with a convincing all round performance from the Sport Contact 5. Only dropping out of the top three twice, the Sport Contact 5 excelled in both subjective feel and objective handling. The aging, but updated Pirelli P Zero had a good result in second place, largely down to wet and dry handling, and the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2 rounded out the top three, with the usual Goodyear blend of wet grip and steering feel.

 

The Rest

Fourth spot was taken by Yokohama, with the AD08. It was a surprising nomination from Yokohama, with the Advan V105 the logical choice, but the gamble paid off. Easily the most exciting and fastest tire in the dry, it wasn't as awful as some track day tires in the wet, giving you an "extreme performance" tire you can drive all year.

Michelin finished fifth, with a good all round performance, but we tend to feel the French brand was disadvantaged by the small size chosen. The Michelin Pilot Super Sport would have been the logical competitor to the other tires on test, but starting in 18 inches Michelin had to put forward the softer, more touring orientated Pilot Sport 3.

Vredestein entered the replacement to the Ultrac Sessanta, the Vorti, and will be happy they beat Toyo and Hankook to win the battle of the midrange tires. Dunlop disappointed in ninth struggling with overall grip, and Bridgestone embarrassingly finished last at home, with neither good feel or good grip.

 

Sidewall Stiffness

One thing we're always being asked is "does sidewall stiffness relate to handling?" To try and answer this, we visited the warehouse at lovetires.com and measured the sidewall stiffness of each tire on test with a totally unscientific  "squeeze test".

Expecting to find an approximate correlation between the best subjective tires on test, and the stiffest sidewalls, the results surprised us. Here is the order of stiffness, grouped into approximate stiffness groups, and the subjective dry handling result. 

Tire in order of sidewall stiffness Subjective dry position
Yokohama 1st
Group 2  
Vredestein 7th
Bridgestone 9th
Toyo 6th
Hankook 4th
Michelin 8th
Group 3  
Pirelli 2nd
Continental 2nd
Goodyear 5th
Dunlop 10th

The best and worst in group are in the right places, but there's no pattern between second place and ninth! Obviously there's more at work than basic sidewall stiffness to subjective handling.

It is however worth noting, subjective handling isn't just down to the tire - it's how the car works with the tire, the tire size on test, and what that particular writer values while driving. For example, we've tested various tires in 19 inch on an E46 BMW M3, and the Bridgestone Potenza S001 is the best we've tried for pure steering feel and feedback (but not outright grip.)

Sadly, with no easy formula to subjective tire feel, it looks like you have to look into detailed user reviews on your chosen vehicle. 

 

The Results

Below are the full results. Please note, we've not included aquaplaning scores, or applied any weighting, so make sure you pick up a copy of EVO issue 201 (November 2014) for the test in its full glory. Also we entered the EVO road route test as "comfort", but EVO took into account comfort, noise and steering feel.

1st

Continental Sport Contact 5

225/45 R17
Continental Sport Contact 5
With four wins, and only twice dropping out of the top three, it was a convincing win for Continental with the Sport Contact 5. Both subjectively and objectively, the Sport Contact 5 is a joy to drive
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry98.3
Wet100
Subjective189.4
Comfort95.3
Rolling Resistance80.8
Cost87.2

Total: 651

2nd

Pirelli P Zero

225/45 R17
Pirelli P Zero
While being a relatively old pattern, the updated P Zero put in a very strong performance in the key wet and dry handling tests. Often the only tire to get close to the Continental in outright grip
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry98.4
Wet99.5
Subjective185.7
Comfort90.7
Rolling Resistance76
Cost86.6

Total: 636.9

3rd

Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2

225/45 R17
Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2
While the now aging Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2 failed to win any categories, its consistent placing in all tests resulted in a top three finish. Easy to judge levels of grip, and progressive over the limit
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry98.1
Wet99.3
Subjective166.9
Comfort86
Rolling Resistance90.8
Cost99.8

Total: 640.9

4th

Yokohama Advan Neova AD08

225/45 R17
Yokohama Advan Neova AD08
Yokohma took a gamble when it nominated the AD08 instead of the V105, but it paid off. Sensational in the dry, surprisingly "ok" in the wet, and performing well on the road too, the AD08 is a trackday tire you can drive every day
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry100
Wet93.5
Subjective173.9
Comfort97.7
Rolling Resistance67.4
Cost71.1

Total: 603.6

5th

Michelin Pilot Sport 3 PS3

225/45 R17
Michelin Pilot Sport 3 PS3
Winning both aquaplaning tests and the road route, there was plenty to like about the Michelin and its weighty steering feel
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry97.4
Wet97.8
Subjective152.4
Comfort100
Rolling Resistance76.1
Cost82.8

Total: 606.5

6th

Vredestein Ultrac Vorti

225/45 R17
Vredestein Ultrac Vorti
Similar performance to the seventh place Toyo, the Vredestein Ultrac Vorti was mostly a "mid table" tire throughout the tests. It did well in wet handling, where it inspired confidence and finished third on the road route thanks to being comfortable and quiet
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry97.6
Wet96.7
Subjective157.1
Comfort95.3
Rolling Resistance69.5
Cost92.2

Total: 608.4

7th

Toyo Proxes T1 Sport

225/45 R17
Toyo Proxes T1 Sport
Seventh seems like a fair place for the Toyo T1 Sport. It didn't really excel in any tests, performing slightly better in the wet handling tests than the dry, but offered better feel when the roads were dry. Reasonably priced
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry97.1
Wet96.6
Subjective160.2
Comfort83.7
Rolling Resistance71.5
Cost97.9

Total: 607

8th

Hankook Ventus S1 evo2

225/45 R17
Hankook Ventus S1 evo2
The Hankook S1 Evo 2 had both good results, and bad. Strong in aquaplaning, and mid pack in dry handling, the tire was let down by a last place finish in wet handling and a poor score on the road route section
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry97.9
Wet95.6
Subjective152.9
Comfort81.4
Rolling Resistance79.7
Cost94.3

Total: 601.8

9th

Dunlop Sport Maxx RT

225/45 R17
Dunlop Sport Maxx RT
Well priced, best rolling resistance, good feel with the limit eas to judge, let down by the limit not being higher
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry96.7
Wet96.3
Subjective129.7
Comfort93
Rolling Resistance100
Cost100

Total: 615.7

10th

Bridgestone Potenza S001

225/45 R17
Bridgestone Potenza S001
The home advantage counting for nothing, the Bridgestone S001 finished last, struggling in both the subjective and measured tests
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry97.3
Wet96.5
Subjective127.6
Comfort93
Rolling Resistance75.1
Cost92.9

Total: 582.4

More tire tests

Cross-check this test

All tire tests

Where these tires were tested again, and how the verdict held up.

Discussion

6 comments
  1. Fernando qWarner archived

    This is very nice and really appreciating.
    you can also visit http://www.acrinffga.com/ for more information.
    f

    #1305
  2. Daniel Klinkhammer archived

    are these tires the "top ten" or were there more tires tested?

    #1209
  3. Papathanasiou Stavros archived

    the pirelli in this test is xl / 94 load ?

    #1207
      1. Papathanasiou Stavros TireReviews archived

        The fact that pzero is 94Y XL but with low stiffness and pretty good comfort is really impressive .

        #1221
Rate your tires

My tires

Saved in this browser on this site. No account needed. Clearing browser data removes your choices.

Vehicle and size

Check the size, load and speed ratings on your vehicle. Saving a size does not confirm fitment.

Saved tires

Save tires from a tire page, test or comparison to keep them here.

Select 2–8 saved tires. Ranked comparisons require at least two shared tests.

Where to buy

Affiliate links: if you buy, we may earn a commission. It never changes our tests, scores or recommendations. How we stay independent