Menu

Best Tires for the Audi S5

Audi S5 drivers have left 44 tire reviews on Tire Reviews, covering 402,801 miles of real world driving. Every tire they rated is ranked below, so you can see what actually works on this car.

  • 44owner reviews
  • 402,801 milescovered on them
  • 31different tires rated
  • 81%average tire score
Most fitted size - 19 reviews 255/35 R19 To scale, mm
Ø 661 255 89 19" 89 All 255/35 R19 data →

The quick answer

The quick answer - Audi S5
Season Owners' pick Owner rating Our category test
Summer Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 9.2 Current version: Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 6 83% from 5 reviews Best Summer Tires

Highest weighted owner score from Audi S5 drivers. Full rankings and the evidence behind them below.

The best rated tires for the Audi S5

Rated only by drivers of this car. Each tire needs at least 3 reviews from the Audi S5 to be ranked; the order weights a tire's score by how many reviews back it, so one glowing review cannot top a table.

Summer tires

The highest rated tire in the Summer category for the Audi S5 is the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 - 83% from 5 owner reviews across 18,003 miles. The current tire in that line is now the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 6.

Summer tires ranked by Audi S5 owner rating
# Tire Owner rating Reviews Distance reviewed TR Score
1 Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 Replaced by Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 6 83% 5 18,003 miles 9.2
2 Dunlop SP Sport Maxx GT 76% 6 105,500 miles 5.5

Want test data as well as owner opinion? Best Summer Tires →

TR Score is the tire's overall Tire Reviews rating out of 10, built from independent test results and every owner review of that tire - not just the reviews from this car. The owner rating column is this car only.

The best rated tires that fit the Audi S5

The rankings above can only speak for tires a Audi S5 driver has already reviewed. These are the highest rated tires we hold that are actually manufactured in the sizes these drivers run - 255/35 R19, 245/40 R18, 245/45 R18 and 265/30 R20 - whether or not anyone here has fitted them yet. They are ranked on the TR Score, which is built from independent test results and every owner review of that tire.

Summer tires

Our highest rated tire in the Summer category, in this car's sizes, is the Continental SportContact 7, at 9.7 out of 10.

Highest rated Summer tires made in Audi S5 sizes
# Tire TR Score Made in Audi S5 reviews
1 Continental SportContact 7 9.7 All your sizes Be the first →
2 Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 6 9.7 255/35 R19, 245/40 R18, 245/45 R18 Be the first →
3 Bridgestone Potenza Sport Evo 9.5 255/35 R19, 245/40 R18, 245/45 R18 Be the first →
4 Continental PremiumContact 7 9.5 245/40 R18, 245/45 R18 Be the first →
5 Michelin Pilot Sport 4 S 9.4 All your sizes 2
6 Hankook Ventus Evo 9.4 All your sizes Be the first →

Want test data as well as owner opinion? Best Summer Tires →

Winter tires

No Audi S5 driver has reviewed a tire in the Winter category yet. Of the ones made in this car's sizes, the Pirelli P Zero Winter 2 is our highest rated, at 9.8 out of 10.

Highest rated Winter tires made in Audi S5 sizes
# Tire TR Score Made in Audi S5 reviews
1 Pirelli P Zero Winter 2 9.8 All your sizes Be the first →
2 Hankook Winter I*cept Evo 4 9.6 All your sizes Be the first →
3 Goodyear UltraGrip Performance 3 9.5 All your sizes Be the first →
4 Michelin Pilot Alpin 5 9.5 255/35 R19, 245/40 R18, 245/45 R18 Be the first →
5 Michelin Alpin 7 9.5 245/40 R18, 245/45 R18 Be the first →
6 Bridgestone Blizzak 6 9.4 All your sizes Be the first →

Want test data as well as owner opinion? Best Winter Tires → Test winner: Goodyear UltraGrip Performance 3

All Season tires

No Audi S5 driver has reviewed a tire in the All Season category yet. Of the ones made in this car's sizes, the Michelin CrossClimate 3 Sport is our highest rated, at 9.6 out of 10.

Highest rated All Season tires made in Audi S5 sizes
# Tire TR Score Made in Audi S5 reviews
1 Michelin CrossClimate 3 Sport 9.6 All your sizes Be the first →
2 Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 9.6 255/35 R19, 245/40 R18, 245/45 R18 Be the first →
3 Continental AllSeasonContact 2 9.5 255/35 R19, 245/40 R18, 245/45 R18 Be the first →
4 BFGoodrich Advantage All Season 9.5 255/35 R19, 245/40 R18, 245/45 R18 Be the first →
5 Michelin CrossClimate 3 9.5 245/45 R18 Be the first →
6 Michelin Pilot Sport All Season 4 9.4 All your sizes Be the first →

Want test data as well as owner opinion? Best All Season Tires → Test winner: Goodyear Vector All Season 4

All Weather tires

No Audi S5 driver has reviewed a tire in the All Weather category yet. Of the ones made in this car's sizes, the Vredestein Quatrac 5 is our highest rated, at 8.4 out of 10.

Highest rated All Weather tires made in Audi S5 sizes
# Tire TR Score Made in Audi S5 reviews
1 Vredestein Quatrac 5 8.4 255/35 R19, 245/40 R18, 245/45 R18 Be the first →
2 Vredestein Quatrac Pro+ 8.1 255/35 R19, 245/40 R18, 245/45 R18 Be the first →
3 Vredestein Quatrac Pro 8 255/35 R19, 245/40 R18, 245/45 R18 Be the first →

Want test data as well as owner opinion? Best All Weather Tires →

Fitment comes from each tire's manufactured size list, and the sizes are the ones drivers reported when they reviewed. Check the size, load index and speed rating on your own doorplate before buying - a size a previous owner ran is not always the size your car left the factory on.

Every tire reviewed on the Audi S5

The complete record, including discontinued tires and tires with too few reviews to rank, ordered by the amount of evidence. A further 25 tires have a single review each; they count toward the totals but are not listed.

All tires reviewed by Audi S5 drivers
Tire Season Owner rating Reviews Distance reviewed
Dunlop SP Sport Maxx GT Summer 76% 6 105,500 miles
Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 Replaced by Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 6 Summer 83% 5 18,003 miles
Blackhawk Street H HU02 Summer 100% 2 43,500 miles
Michelin Pilot Sport 4 S Replaced by Michelin Pilot Sport S 5 Summer 91% 2 7,000 miles
Continental ExtremeContact DWS 06 PLUS All Season 86% 2 6,228 miles
Firestone Firehawk Sport Summer 77% 2 5,500 miles

Tire sizes Audi S5 drivers run

The sizes fitted in the reviews on this page. Each one links to the top rated tires in that size, across every car.

What Audi S5 drivers say

The most recent owner reviews from this car, in their own words.

100%
Blackhawk Street H HU02 255-35-19 Audi S5 18,500 miles October 26, 2026

The tires have been absolutely brilliant in my opinion. So far, the tires have performed way above their price point, and would definitely choose them again.

82%
Goodyear Eagle F1 SuperSport 245-35-20 Audi S5 10,000 miles September 10, 2026

So far so good. These came in as OE in my audi s5. So I dont have experience with other tires in this car.

Still, the way I can turn my handles and not lose grip is impressive. I experienced minimal roll, I think the car also contributes a bit on this aspect.
When the tire is warmed up and is dry, I have much confidence to push.
I dont like to drive hard in the wet, so I cant say much on that part.

The wear is surprisingly not bad. Maybe its because I dont do track days.
I do push my tires/car time to time, launches and fast braking, driving in curvy mountain roads etc. But the treads seem quite ok at 16000km (~10000miles)

Comfort level, not so great, not so bad. But who would buy this tire expecting high comfort level right? At least its not destroying my butt, I am fine.

Would definitely buy again. But the price of these tires are quite through the roof in Korea at the moment. I really like these tires, but I will definitely try other brands for comparison as well.

Good tire for sure.

93%
Yokohama ADVAN APEX V601 225-45-17 Audi S5 1,250 miles May 1, 2026
2014 Audi S5

Having driven over 1200 miles on these tires with countless launches, these tires have been perfect. Running a 10.8 1/4mile and a 2.9 0-60mph on this set up, it honestly was a great buy. I recenlty also did a 600 mile road trip in the same car and tire setup, it was a very nice drive with minimal road noise and great handling around the curves. There were really no issues personally, but noticed that it would need to get quite warm before max performance which is normal.

Overall great buy !
99%
Blackhawk Street H HU02 255-35-19 Audi S5 25,000 miles January 23, 2026
Don't let the fact that they are manufactured in China throw you off. B9 S5 Coupe driver, and I am now on my second set, and gladly waited for my service center to source the tires instead of fitting another brand. My service center had not had previous experience with Blackhawk tires, hence the reason for trying to get me to switch - until I showed them reviews and comparisons between what they were recommending me and what I wanted. They then made the effort to source the tires for me (even though there was basically no stock at any of the suppliers they purchase from). If you're looking for a solid, quality, budget-friendly tire, you will be hard-pressed to find a better solution. Excellent, excellent tires.
40%
Haida HD921 255-35-19 Audi S5 18,000 miles December 3, 2025
They are mostly ok when they've got lots of tread in the dry, side walls don't hold up well to fast driving/cornering, expect lots of understeer, they got worse and worse as they wore down, in the wet they were ok but as they've wore down to 4mm and below I would rate these tires as down right dangerous in the rain, expect them to aquaplane, if you have them on all 4 and you are going 70, I would expect it your car to probably spin out, thankfully I only have them on my fronts as they were on there when I bought the car, do not buy these unless you absolutely have too.
64%
Firestone Firehawk Sport 265-30-20- Audi S5 4,000 miles December 5, 2024
Good while they lasted....5 months from purchase, and less than 4,000 miles later, one nearside tire is damaged / leaking (plus a chunk has delaminated and a crack appeared without any sign of alloy contact), and the rear nearside tire's rim protection has cracked. I'm very annoyed; the previous Toyos I had fitted - identical specification and a similar soft rubber - experienced exactly the same local roads / potholes for over 4 years without issue, plus the tires on our other cars haven't suffered either (running Toyo and Nexen tires for 5 years and 7 years respectively, the latter on a very heavy 4x4).

I can only conclude that whatever material used is far too soft to deal with the state of English roads - which is not much help if you live here. Needless to say, I avoid potholes whenever possible or driving in the gutter, keep tires at the correct pressures etc. The picture uploaded is the most concerning as there is no damage to the alloy / sign of impact to the tire, so quite what has caused the cracking here is a mystery.

This has turned out to be the most expensive set of tires for the mileage that I've purchased in 40 years, and I'm disappointed as these tires seemed great at the outset in respect of handling/grip in the wet and lack of noise - my two chief criteria. I can only assume that these tires are simply not up to the job for whatever reason, and I will be contacting the supplier to complain.
96%
Bridgestone Potenza Sport 255-35-19- Audi S5 5,000 miles November 20, 2024
The tire as a whole is very nice and reliable, but care must be taken because the grip on dry when the tire is cold is less. However, once it reaches operating temperature the feeling is wonderful ! The feedback from the road and the feel in a corner is second to none. In the wet it also performs super. Just be careful on cold tarmac with cold tires - then there is a loss of grip. I've been driving the tires for about 8,000km, but it feels like the wear is a bit faster than I'd like.
50%
Giti GitiSportS2 235-40-19- Audi S5 15,000 miles November 16, 2024
Been using this tire since October 2024, however during today balancing and Allignment check, 3pcs of the tire was bloated and unusable, need to replace new tire. Disappointed with Giti Tire. Defiantly will not buy again. Piece of junk product from China.
84%
Continental ExtremeContact DWS 06 PLUS 265-35-19- Audi S5 28 miles September 23, 2024
It’s the perfect tire for my needs. I live in the Pacific Northwest, where it rains a lot and snows occasionally. I don’t need a dedicated snow tire, but the Continental DWS 06+ is an awesome all-around tire. I couldn’t fit two cars in one review, so I added another one just because why not? I bought another set for my wife’s Hyundai Elantra, but I wasn’t as happy with them. Her car has smaller wheels (205/55R16), which meant a thicker sidewall, which made the handling feel a bit squishy. I’m aware there are more factors that affect it besides a thicker sidewall. I know the Elantra isn’t as good or as fun to drive as my Audi S5, but it’s still an amazing all-around tire regardless of what vehicle it’s on.
90%
Firestone Firehawk Sport 265-30-20- Audi S5 1,500 miles July 12, 2024
Excellent tires for wet roads - no slipping when accelerating / overtaking / cornering, or when hitting unseen standing water, or more generally, bouncing around on poorly-surfaced potholed roads - so well-suited to driving in England this Summer... Also grip well in the dry, and they're quiet at lower speeds - very important for a convertible which came with large, wide alloys and rubber-band tires. Am also achieving more miles per gallon - never seen 33 mpg previously (30 was the best) - so as nothing else has changed, the new tires' construction/composition must be responsible. Plus, they were attractively priced.

Have only driven 1,500 miles so far, but pleased that I took a gamble on tires with barely any reviews available. These are certainly better than previous Toyo Proxes or Falkens, and seem to be more in line with the parent Bridgestone's tire designs (mine are made in Poland, not Italy as the website suggests). I've long preferred Japanese tire designs for their combination of grip, comfort and quietness, although they tend to wear down faster, after disappointing experiences with the main Italian and German offerings.

Drive a Audi S5?

Review your tires and help the next owner choose. It takes about five minutes, and every review on this page came from a driver who took them.

Review Your Tires

Where this data comes from

Every rating on this page was submitted by a driver through the review form on this site, naming the car, the tire, the size and the distance covered. Reviews are checked by hand before publication, and the page rebuilds automatically as new ones arrive.

About the TR Score

The Tire Reviews Score rates each tire out of 10 using independent test results and the full body of owner reviews, so you can check a car-specific ranking against the wider evidence.

Who does the testing

Every test published as a Tire Reviews test is run by Jonathan Benson, who has been testing tires independently since 2007.

Rate your tires

My tires

Saved in this browser on this site. No account needed. Clearing browser data removes your choices.

Vehicle and size

Check the size, load and speed ratings on your vehicle. Saving a size does not confirm fitment.

Saved tires

Save tires from a tire page, test or comparison to keep them here.

Select 2–8 saved tires. Ranked comparisons require at least two shared tests.