Menu

Michelin Primacy 5 Test Results

Tire Reviews tests: 2 Tested 2024 to 2026 14 publications

Tested 15 times by independent publications, the Michelin Primacy 5 has taken 3 test wins with an average finish of 4th. Its strongest discipline is Rolling Resistance, beating 86% of the field across 10 tests; its weakest is Wet Circle, at 24% across 7 tests.

  • 15Independent tests
  • 3Test wins
  • 5Podium finishes
  • 4thAverage finish
  • 59%Field beaten on average
  • 14Publications
Michelin Primacy 5

15 tests, 2024 to 2026

0%50%100%202420252026Average 59%2024 TUV and DEKRA Test of Michelin Primacy 5 vs Rivals (2024): P1 of 5, Beat 75% of the field2025 Summer and All Season Combined Tire Test (2025): P1 of 14, Beat 100% of the field2025 Al Volante Summer Tire Test (2025): P4 of 7, Beat 50% of the field2025 Die ReifenTester Summer Touring Tire Test (2025): P5 of 7, Beat 33% of the fieldMichelin CrossClimate 3 & 3 Sport vs Pilot Sport 5 vs Primacy 5 (2025): P2 of 4, Beat 67% of the field2025 DEKRA Wear Test of Michelin Primacy 5 Energy vs Rivals (2025): P1 of 8, Beat 86% of the field2026 Auto Zeitung 18 Inch Summer Tire Test (2026): P6 of 10, Beat 44% of the field2026 ADAC Summer Tire Test (2026): P7 of 16, Beat 60% of the fieldThe BEST Summer Tires for 2026 Tested and Rated (2026): P6 of 12, Beat 55% of the field2026 Vi Bilagare Summer Tire Test (2026): P6 of 10, Beat 44% of the field2026 Summer ECO Tire Test (2026): P3 of 8, Beat 71% of the field2026 Motor Summer Tire Test (2026): P5 of 9, Beat 50% of the field2026 autozurnal Eco Summer Tire Test (2026): P4 of 10, Beat 67% of the field2026 Auto Express Summer Tire Test (2026): P6 of 8, Beat 29% of the field
Share of the field beaten in each test, oldest to newest. Hover or tap a point for the test.
  • Test win
  • Second
  • Third
  • Average 59%
The latest test

2026 Auto Express Summer Tire Test P6 of 8

The Michelin Primacy 5 is a specialist rather than an all-rounder in this company. Its efficiency advantage is large enough to be worth real money over a set's life, and its wet braking is genuinely competitive, but both handling circuits expose it against a strong field. Buy it for the running costs and the wet stopping distance; look elsewhere if you want a tire that rewards being driven hard.

Strong: Rolling Resistance Weak: Dry Handling, Wet Handling, Noise Winner: Falken ZIEX ZE320

Record by discipline

Where the Michelin Primacy 5 finished in each measured discipline, across every test that measured it against at least two other tires. Field beaten is the share of the other tires it outranked in that measurement.

Discipline Tests Avg finish Field beaten Firsts
Dry
Dry Braking 14 P6.1 of 8.9 35% -
Dry Handling 7 P6.1 of 8.1 28% -
Subj. Dry Handling 7 P4.4 of 10.4 60% 1
Wet
Wet Braking 14 P4.4 of 8.9 55% 1
Wet Braking - Concrete 1 P8 of 16 53% -
Wet Handling 11 P5 of 8.9 48% -
Subj. Wet Handling 4 P4.5 of 11 59% 1
Wet Circle Weak 7 P7.6 of 9.6 24% -
Straight Aqua 12 P3.3 of 9.7 71% 1
Curved Aquaplaning 8 P4.5 of 9.4 60% -
Comfort
Subj. Comfort 6 P1.8 of 9.8 91% 2
Subj. Noise 3 P3.3 of 10.3 69% 1
Noise 7 P3.7 of 9.3 67% 2
Rough Noise 1 P8 of 10 22% -
Value
Wear 4 P1.3 of 9.8 98% 3
Value 1 P5 of 10 56% -
Rolling Resistance Strong 10 P2.2 of 8.9 86% 4
Fuel Consumption 2 P1.5 of 13 94% 1
Energy Consumption 2 P5.5 of 9 45% -
Abrasion 4 P1.3 of 9.8 96% 3

Head-to-head record

Overall finishing position against the tires that have most often shared a test with the Michelin Primacy 5. Only tires tested alongside it at least three times are listed.

Rival Shared tests Ahead Behind Level Finished ahead
Continental PremiumContact 7 11 shared: 2 ahead, 8 behind Compare with PremiumContact 7 11 2 8 1 20%
Pirelli Cinturato C3 9 shared: 1 ahead, 8 behind Compare with Cinturato C3 9 1 8 - 11%
Bridgestone Turanza 6 7 shared: 4 ahead, 3 behind Compare with Turanza 6 7 4 3 - 57%
Maxxis Premitra HP6 6 shared: 5 ahead, 1 behind Compare with Premitra HP6 6 5 1 - 83%
Firestone Roadhawk 2 ENLITEN 6 shared: 2 ahead, 4 behind Compare with Roadhawk 2 ENLITEN 6 2 4 - 33%
Hankook Ventus Prime 4 5 shared: 5 ahead, 0 behind Compare with Ventus Prime 4 5 5 0 - 100%
Falken ZIEX ZE320 5 shared: 1 ahead, 4 behind Compare with ZIEX ZE320 5 1 4 - 20%
Vredestein Ultrac+ 4 shared: 3 ahead, 1 behind Compare with Ultrac+ 4 3 1 - 75%
Goodyear EfficientGrip Performance 2 4 shared: 2 ahead, 2 behind Compare with EfficientGrip Performance 2 4 2 2 - 50%
Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 6 3 shared: 1 ahead, 2 behind Compare with Eagle F1 Asymmetric 6 3 1 2 - 33%

Against its own line

The same record for the tire it replaced and the tire that replaced it.

Tire Tests Wins Avg finish Field beaten
Michelin Primacy 4+ Predecessor 12 1 4th 62%
Michelin Primacy 5 This tire 15 3 4th 59%

Performance Analysis

Drawn from 13 tests. Updated September 29, 2026.

Across 13 independent tests, the Michelin Primacy 5 repeatedly presents as a premium touring tire optimized for low energy loss, comfort and longevity rather than outright dynamic sharpness. The evidence is strong and consistent: it often leads efficiency metrics (e.g. 1st of 8 for rolling resistance in the 2026 Auto Express test; 1st of 16 for fuel consumption and 2nd of 16 for wear in the 2026 ADAC test; 1st of 10 for rolling resistance and 1st of 10 for wear in the 2026 Auto Zeitung test), and it is frequently among the most refined (e.g. 1st of 9 for noise and 1st for comfort in the 2026 Motor test; “most comfortable... low noise” in the 2026 Michelin range test). Aquaplaning resistance is another recurring plus, with multiple top-three results (e.g. straight aquaplaning 1st of 14 in the 2025 UTAC/Aftonbladet test; 2nd of 12 in the 2026 Tire Reviews test; 2nd of 9 in the 2026 Motor test). Overall placings tend to land mid to upper-mid pack (average 4.3), with a single standout win (1st of 14 in the 2025 UTAC/Aftonbladet combined test) and one “Recommended” award (2026 Tire Reviews).

Where it most often gives ground is in steering immediacy and ultimate handling precision, particularly in wet handling feel and, in some tests, dry braking. Testers repeatedly describe soft or imprecise responses (“needs larger steering angles... lacks precision” in 2026 Auto Zeitung; “soft on initial steering response” in the 2026 Michelin range test; “imprecise steering and thermal sensitivity” in 2026 ADAC), and this is reflected in weaker handling placings in several strong group tests (e.g. 8/8 in dry handling and 7/8 in wet handling in 2026 Auto Express). Braking performance is generally safe but seldom class-leading on dry (commonly ~5-10% off best), while wet braking swings from excellent (1st of 14 in 2025 UTAC/Aftonbladet; 2nd of 10, +1.3% from best in 2026 autozurnal) to merely mid-pack (e.g. 9th of 12, +7.5% in 2026 Tire Reviews; 8th of 10, +9.3% in 2026 Vi Bilagare).

Performance Strengths

Performance Weaknesses

Do owners agree with the tests?

Every tester write-up on the Michelin Primacy 5 (13 tests) and 62 owner reviews were tagged for the aspects they judge. Where both have spoken, this is how they line up.

Where owners and testers agree

  • Ride comfort strength in 5 of 13 tests 36 praise, 2 criticise of 62 reviews · Read those reviews
  • Rolling resistance strength in 10 of 13 tests 15 praise, 1 criticise of 62 reviews · Read those reviews
  • Aquaplaning resistance strength in 6 of 13 tests 9 praise, 1 criticise of 62 reviews · Read those reviews
  • Tread life strength in 3 of 13 tests 10 praise, 1 criticise of 62 reviews · Read those reviews

Raised by owners, not by any test of this tire

  • Dry grip no test mentions it 16 praise, 4 criticise of 62 reviews · Read those reviews
  • Value for money no test mentions it 6 praise, 2 criticise of 62 reviews · Read those reviews

Every test, newest first 15

Strong = top two of the field in that measurement. Weak = bottom two.

2026 9 tests
P6 of 8 Beat 29% of the field

2026 Auto Express Summer Tire Test

Auto Express 205/55 R16

The Michelin Primacy 5 is a specialist rather than an all-rounder in this company. Its efficiency advantage is large enough to be worth real money over a set's life, and its wet braking is genuinely competitive, but both handling circuits expose it against a strong field. Buy it for the running costs and the wet stopping distance; look elsewhere if you want a tire that rewards being driven hard.

StrongRolling Resistance WeakDry HandlingWet HandlingNoise WinnerFalken ZIEX ZE320

Not ranked Summer

Michelin Range Test - CrossClimate 3, 3 Sport, Primacy 5, Pilot Sport 5 and Cup 2

Tire Reviews 225/40 R18 Tested by Tire Reviews

The Michelin Primacy 5 is the premium touring summer tire in this range and it sets the efficiency and comfort standard for the whole test. It is a quiet, economical, safe and thoroughly predictable tire for drivers who cover a lot of road miles and do not need sporting feel. Just do not ask it to work in winter, because that is not what it was built for.

StrongRolling Resistance WeakDry BrakingDry Handling

P4 of 10 Beat 67% of the field

2026 autozurnal Eco Summer Tire Test

Autozurnal 215/55 R18 dobrý (Good)

Michelin Primacy 5 secured fourth place overall. The tester noted that this specific set was surprisingly manufactured in China, which might have contributed to it being one of the heavier premium tires at 10.81 kg. Despite the weight, it performed admirably in safety tests, taking third place in both longitudinal and transverse aquaplaning.

StrongWet BrakingSubj. Comfort WinnerHankook iON Evo

P5 of 9 Beat 50% of the field

2026 Motor Summer Tire Test

Motor 225/45 R17

The Michelin Primacy 5 finishes fifth, behind two mid-segment tires, which is disappointing for a premium product. Its wet performance is uneven - aquaplaning resistance is good, but lateral grip on wet surfaces is the lowest in the test. Dry performance is average. On the positive side, it has low rolling resistance, produces the least noise at city speeds, and rides comfortably.

StrongStraight AquaSubj. ComfortNoiseRolling Resistance WeakWet BrakingWet HandlingWet Circle WinnerContinental PremiumContact 7

P3 of 8 Beat 71% of the field

2026 Summer ECO Tire Test

Sport Auto 195/55 R16 gut (Good)

The Michelin Primacy 5 delivers balanced and safe handling on both wet and dry surfaces, with enough cornering reserve to remain controllable at the limit. Test drivers noted good aquaplaning protection. On dry roads, however, braking distances are longer than average, and the tire felt somewhat unstable during fast lane-change maneuvers. Ride comfort is a weak point due to low self-damping, making it feel firm over bumps. It sits in the middle of the field for rolling resistance and is the most expensive tire in the test at 135 euros. Overall, it offers predictable, secure behavior without standout performance in any single area.

StrongStraight AquaCurved Aquaplaning WeakDry BrakingWet Circle WinnerDunlop Blue Response TG

P6 of 10 Beat 44% of the field

2026 Vi Bilagare Summer Tire Test

Vi Bilagare 205/55 R16

Michelin Primacy 5 delivers one of the most pleasant driving experiences in the test. Steering feel is refined with good straight-line stability, qualities that are appreciated in daily use. When pushed hard, it communicates grip levels clearly and stays easy to drive beyond the limit. Ride comfort is good over joints and bumps, though noise increases noticeably on coarse asphalt. Rolling resistance is among the lowest. The downside is that braking distances are only average on both wet and dry surfaces, and wet curve grip falls below the group mean.

StrongSubj. Dry HandlingSubj. ComfortFuel Consumption WeakWet Circle WinnerContinental PremiumContact 7

P6 of 12 Beat 55% of the field

The BEST Summer Tires for 2026 Tested and Rated

Tire Reviews 225/45 R17 Tested by Tire Reviews Recommended

The Michelin Primacy 5 finished 6th overall and earned a Recommended award. It was one of the more road-leaning tires in the test, combining 2nd best rolling resistance with good comfort results, including a strong subjective comfort score and a good measured noise reading. In wet aquaplaning it did well in the straight-line test, but objective wet grip was more mid-pack and the wet circle result was towards the back. Dry performance followed a similar pattern: safe and usable, but not a leader for braking or handling.

StrongStraight AquaRolling Resistance WeakWet Circle WinnerPirelli Cinturato C3

P7 of 16 Beat 60% of the field

2026 ADAC Summer Tire Test

ADAC 225/50 R17

The Primacy 5 also misses a good safety rating. The summary describes imprecise steering and thermal sensitivity on dry and wet roads, although braking on both surfaces is good. Its environmental rating is the best in the test: the tire offers very high predicted mileage, the lowest abrasion and low weight, and it achieves the lowest fuel consumption among all candidates. Consequently, ADAC gives only a conditional recommendation, noting good braking and excellent efficiency but shortcomings in overall handling.

StrongWearFuel ConsumptionAbrasion WinnerContinental PremiumContact 7

P6 of 10 Beat 44% of the field

2026 Auto Zeitung 18 Inch Summer Tire Test

Auto Zeitung 235/45 R18 Sehr empfehlenswert / Umwelt-Empfehlung (Highly Recommended / Eco Recommendation)

The Michelin Primacy 5 is clearly designed with efficiency and longevity as its top priorities, and the test data confirms this. It records the lowest rolling resistance, the highest predicted tread life, the lowest abrasion, and the best comfort score in the group. It is also one of the quieter tires. However, this focus on durability and low energy loss comes at the expense of wet grip. On wet roads the Michelin needs larger steering angles than the best tires and lacks precision in its responses. Wet braking distances are extended compared to the leaders, which is a meaningful safety concern. On dry roads a strong understeer tendency limits the tire's ability to change direction quickly, holding back its dynamic performance even though outright lap times are reasonable. The high purchase price is the highest in the test, but the long expected life goes some way to offsetting that on a cost-per-kilometer basis. This is a tire for drivers who prioritize fuel economy, low wear, and a quiet, comfortable ride over outright wet grip and sporty handling.

StrongSubj. ComfortWearRolling ResistanceAbrasion WinnerContinental PremiumContact 7

2025 5 tests
P2 of 4 Beat 67% of the field

Michelin CrossClimate 3 & 3 Sport vs Pilot Sport 5 vs Primacy 5

Auto Motor Und Sport 225/40 R18

The Michelin Primacy 5 proved to be a highly competitive summer touring tire, performing much closer to the UHP Pilot Sport 5 than expected. Its dry handling lap was only 1.4 seconds slower, and its braking distance was just 4 feet longer. In the wet, the Primacy 5 was particularly impressive. Its handling time was just 0.6 seconds off the pace of the Pilot Sport 5, and the driver noted it was enjoyable and very controllable, making it a confidence-inspiring tire in challenging conditions.

StrongDry BrakingDry HandlingWet BrakingWet Handling WinnerMichelin Pilot Sport 5

P5 of 7 Beat 33% of the field

2025 Die ReifenTester Summer Touring Tire Test

Die Reifentester 205/55 R17

Michelin’s fifth‑generation Primacy behaved like a docile understeerer that has no ambitions to play the first violin. It was praised as a reliable, pleasant tire that does its job unobtrusively and rolls very comfortably. Long life is expected, but its conservative handling meant it finished mid‑pack.

StrongSubj. Comfort WeakDry Braking WinnerFalken ZIEX ZE320

P4 of 7 Beat 50% of the field

2025 Al Volante Summer Tire Test

Al Volante 225/55 R18

The Michelin Primacy 5 achieves a good balance between performance and efficiency. It delivers solid wet performance with good aquaplaning resistance. As the quietest tire in the test with excellent rolling resistance, it's ideal for drivers prioritizing fuel economy and comfort. However, its dry braking is merely average, and it isn't as dynamically capable as the top three performers, with testers noting it isn't particularly responsive when entering corners.

StrongNoiseRolling Resistance WinnerPirelli Cinturato C3

P1 of 14 Beat 100% of the field

2025 Summer and All Season Combined Tire Test

UTAC 225/45 R17

The Michelin Primacy 5 is excellent on wet roads with calm, easy handling and very good grip in corners. It delivers a short braking distance and outstanding resistance to aquaplaning. On dry roads, the Michelin Primacy 5 remains stable and safe, though its braking distance isn't the shortest in the test. Its steering is slightly slower than some competitors during evasive maneuvers. The Michelin Primacy 5 is quiet with low rolling resistance, making it fuel-efficient. The Michelin was the overall test winner with 9.1 points, praised for being incomparably easy to drive and predictable.

StrongSubj. Dry HandlingWet BrakingSubj. Wet HandlingStraight AquaSubj. NoiseRolling Resistance

2024 1 test
P1 of 5 Beat 75% of the field

2024 TUV and DEKRA Test of Michelin Primacy 5 vs Rivals

TUV 205/55 R16

The Primacy 5 was the most efficient and longest-wearing tire here, with competitive rather than class-leading braking, and finished joint first on our weighting with the PremiumContact 7.

StrongWet BrakingWearRolling ResistanceAbrasion

Back to the Michelin Primacy 5 overview

Owner reviews, sizes and EU label data, comparisons and the Tire Reviews score. All Michelin tires

Overview

Rate your tires

My tires

Saved in this browser on this site. No account needed. Clearing browser data removes your choices.

Vehicle and size

Check the size, load and speed ratings on your vehicle. Saving a size does not confirm fitment.

Saved tires

Save tires from a tire page, test or comparison to keep them here.

Select 2–8 saved tires. Ranked comparisons require at least two shared tests.