The German SUV specialist publication Auto Bild Allrad have become the second magazine in 2021 to publish their all season tire test, and the first to include the new Michelin CrossClimate 2 (much to our disappointment, we wanted to be first!)
While the Allrad tests aren't quite as in depth as the industry leading Auto Bild tests, they're still an excellent reference point for the market, and especially useful if you drive an SUV, or are interested in how an all season tire compares to a summer and winter tire, as both are included as references.
The tested size is 215/65 R17, which fits many popular SUVs such as the VW Tiguan test vehicle, the Audi Q5, Mercedes GLA, Nissan Qashqai and many others. It's worth remembering that sometimes SUV tire sizes have different constructions to their regular cousins, meaning that surprising results can be a feature in this sort of test!
Read on to find out exactly what all season tire was good at each category of test!
Dry
Dry braking was unsurprisingly led by the summer tire, with the Michelin CrossClimate 2 taking its usual spot of the best of the all season tires.
The new Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF2 performed well in dry braking to place second of the all season tires, and Maxxis rounded out the top three.
The Continental AllSeasonContact performed poorly, as did the Bridgestone WeatherControl A005 EVO, something we're not used to seeing, but another reminder that SUV sizes sometimes throw up unique results!
Dry Braking
Dry braking in feet
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
RefReference Summer |
116 ft | -9 ft |
| 125 ft | Best | |
| 132 ft | +7 ft | |
| 133 ft | +8 ft | |
| 134 ft | +9 ft | |
| 137 ft | +12 ft | |
| 138 ft | +13 ft | |
| 141 ft | +16 ft | |
| 142 ft | +17 ft | |
| 142 ft | +17 ft | |
| 143 ft | +18 ft | |
RefReference Winter |
152 ft | +27 ft |
The difference between best and worst was 31.1% (36 ft ≈ 2.4 Car Lengths).
The summer tire and Michelin CrossClimate 2 again led the group in dry handling, but this time the Vredestein Quatrac Pro and new Hankook Kinergy 4S2 X rounded out the top three.
Dry Handling
Dry Handling Average Speed
Higher is better ↑| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
RefReference Summer |
65.7 mph | +0.1 mph |
| 65.6 mph | Best | |
| 65.4 mph | -0.2 mph | |
| 65.2 mph | -0.4 mph | |
| 65.1 mph | -0.5 mph | |
| 65.0 mph | -0.6 mph | |
| 64.9 mph | -0.7 mph | |
| 64.7 mph | -0.9 mph | |
| 64.7 mph | -0.9 mph | |
| 64.4 mph | -1.2 mph | |
| 64.4 mph | -1.2 mph | |
RefReference Winter |
64.3 mph | -1.3 mph |
All the tires in the Dry Handling test finished less than 3% apart.
Wet
Wet braking was again led by the summer tire, which indicates the testing was done at warm temperatures. Continental, which was the worst tire in dry braking, was the best in wet braking, with the Vredestein a close second.
Wet Braking
Wet braking in feet
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
RefReference Summer |
152 ft | -6 ft |
| 158 ft | Best | |
| 159 ft | +1 ft | |
RefReference Winter |
162 ft | +4 ft |
| 164 ft | +6 ft | |
| 165 ft | +7 ft | |
| 166 ft | +8 ft | |
| 167 ft | +9 ft | |
| 171 ft | +13 ft | |
| 174 ft | +16 ft | |
| 177 ft | +19 ft | |
| 199 ft | +41 ft |
The difference between best and worst was 31% (47 ft ≈ 3.2 Car Lengths).
Vredestein continued its strong performance in the wet, having the fastest wet handling lap.
Wet Handling
Wet Handling Average Speed
Higher is better ↑| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
| 41.1 mph | Best | |
| 40.8 mph | -0.3 mph | |
RefReference Summer |
40.8 mph | -0.3 mph |
| 40.7 mph | -0.4 mph | |
| 40.5 mph | -0.6 mph | |
| 40.2 mph | -0.9 mph | |
| 39.8 mph | -1.3 mph | |
| 39.5 mph | -1.6 mph | |
RefReference Winter |
39.3 mph | -1.8 mph |
| 39.3 mph | -1.8 mph | |
| 39.0 mph | -2.1 mph | |
| 38.1 mph | -3.0 mph |
The difference between best and worst was 7.4% (3 mph).
Goodyear had the highest levels of safety in the straight aquaplaning test.
Straight Aqua
Float Speed in mph
Higher is better ↑| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
| 53.9 mph | Best | |
| 53.4 mph | -0.5 mph | |
RefReference Winter |
53.4 mph | -0.5 mph |
| 53.1 mph | -0.8 mph | |
RefReference Summer |
52.4 mph | -1.5 mph |
| 51.9 mph | -2.0 mph | |
| 51.9 mph | -2.0 mph | |
| 51.0 mph | -2.9 mph | |
| 50.6 mph | -3.3 mph | |
| 50.3 mph | -3.6 mph | |
| 47.7 mph | -6.2 mph | |
| 46.6 mph | -7.3 mph |
The difference between best and worst was 13.6% (7.3 mph).
Snow
The winter tire led the way in snow braking, with the Hankook and Continental again performing well. The new Michelin CrossClimate has obviously improved snow performance, placing third.
Snow Braking
Snow braking in feet
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
RefReference Winter |
75 ft | -3 ft |
| 78 ft | Best | |
| 78 ft | 0 ft | |
| 80 ft | +2 ft | |
| 80 ft | +2 ft | |
| 81 ft | +3 ft | |
| 81 ft | +3 ft | |
| 81 ft | +3 ft | |
| 82 ft | +4 ft | |
| 82 ft | +4 ft | |
| 83 ft | +5 ft | |
RefReference Summer |
188 ft | +110 ft |
The difference between best and worst was 148.7% (113 ft ≈ 7.6 Car Lengths).
Hankook, Michelin and Continental were again the best in the snow traction test, but this time with Michelin beating its German rival.
Snow Traction
Pulling Force in pounds-force
Higher is better ↑| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
| 791 lbf | Best | |
RefReference Winter |
790 lbf | -1 lbf |
| 785 lbf | -6 lbf | |
| 784 lbf | -7 lbf | |
| 782 lbf | -9 lbf | |
| 774 lbf | -17 lbf | |
| 759 lbf | -32 lbf | |
| 751 lbf | -40 lbf | |
| 726 lbf | -65 lbf | |
| 714 lbf | -77 lbf | |
| 711 lbf | -80 lbf | |
RefReference Summer |
294 lbf | -497 lbf |
The difference between best and worst was 62.9% (497 lbf).
And finally for the grip tests, snow handling was won by Hankook, Continental and Michelin, with all three tires showing an impressive performance in the snow, and close to the full winter tire.
Snow Handling
Snow handling average speed
Higher is better ↑| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
RefReference Winter |
27.3 mph | +0.2 mph |
| 27.1 mph | Best | |
| 27.0 mph | -0.1 mph | |
| 27.0 mph | -0.1 mph | |
| 26.7 mph | -0.4 mph | |
| 26.5 mph | -0.6 mph | |
| 26.4 mph | -0.7 mph | |
| 26.3 mph | -0.8 mph | |
| 26.3 mph | -0.8 mph | |
| 26.1 mph | -1.0 mph | |
| 25.7 mph | -1.4 mph | |
RefReference Summer |
19.9 mph | -7.2 mph |
The difference between best and worst was 27.3% (7.4 mph).
Environment
The new Pirelli was the quietest tire on test with an impressively low noise.
Noise
External noise in dB
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
| 70.8 dB | Best | |
| 71.7 dB | +0.90 dB | |
| 72.2 dB | +1.40 dB | |
RefReference Summer |
72.3 dB | +1.50 dB |
| 72.4 dB | +1.60 dB | |
| 72.5 dB | +1.70 dB | |
| 72.6 dB | +1.80 dB | |
| 72.7 dB | +1.90 dB | |
| 72.7 dB | +1.90 dB | |
| 73.5 dB | +2.70 dB | |
| 73.8 dB | +3.00 dB | |
RefReference Winter |
74.2 dB | +3.40 dB |
The difference between best and worst was 4.8% (3.4 dB).
The CrossClimate 2 led the group again during the rolling resistance test, with Continental and Pirelli close behind.
Rolling Resistance
Rolling resistance in kg t
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best | Extra fuel / year |
|---|---|---|---|
RefReference Summer |
6.66 kg/t | -0.45 kg/t | $0 |
| 7.11 kg/t | Best | $0 | |
| 7.2 kg/t | +0.09 kg/t | $4 | |
| 7.32 kg/t | +0.21 kg/t | $9 | |
| 7.86 kg/t | +0.75 kg/t | $31 | |
| 7.88 kg/t | +0.77 kg/t | $32 | |
| 7.9 kg/t | +0.79 kg/t | $33 | |
| 7.93 kg/t | +0.82 kg/t | $34 | |
RefReference Winter |
8.01 kg/t | +0.90 kg/t | $37 |
| 8.01 kg/t | +0.90 kg/t | $37 | |
| 8.39 kg/t | +1.28 kg/t | $53 | |
| 9.32 kg/t | +2.21 kg/t | $91 |
The difference between best and worst was 39.9% (2.66 kg / t). Over 12,000 miles a year at $3.60/gal, the Cooper Discoverer All Season uses about 25 gal ($91) more fuel than the Michelin CrossClimate 2.
Adjust the assumptions
Calculated estimates, not additional measurements. Use the controls to explore the assumptions.
Finally, the Michelin were the most expensive to buy, however as there's no wear testing in this test, it doesn't tell us anything about the value of the tires.
Results
Hankook Kinergy 4S 2 X
215/65 R17 103V XLCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (11)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 6th / 10 | 138 ft | +13 ft |
| Dry HandlingHigher is better | 3rd / 10 | 65.2 mph | -0.4 mph |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 4th / 10 | 165 ft | +7 ft |
| Wet HandlingHigher is better | 4th / 10 | 40.5 mph | -0.6 mph |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 8th / 10 | 50.3 mph | -3.6 mph |
| Curved AquaplaningHigher is better | 3rd / 10 | 14.6 ft/s² | -1.2 ft/s² |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 1st / 10 | 78 ft | Best in this discipline |
| Snow TractionHigher is better | 1st / 10 | 791 lbf | Best in this discipline |
| Snow HandlingHigher is better | 1st / 10 | 27.1 mph | Best in this discipline |
| NoiseLower is better | 2nd / 10 | 71.7 dB | +0.90 dB |
| Rolling ResistanceLower is better | 6th / 10 | 7.9 kg/t | +0.79 kg/t |
- EU Label
- C/B/72
- Price
- 415.00
Michelin CrossClimate 2
215/65 R17 103V XLCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (11)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 1st / 10 | 125 ft | Best in this discipline |
| Dry HandlingHigher is better | 1st / 10 | 65.6 mph | Best in this discipline |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 7th / 10 | 171 ft | +13 ft |
| Wet HandlingHigher is better | 8th / 10 | 39.3 mph | -1.8 mph |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 6th / 10 | 51.0 mph | -2.9 mph |
| Curved AquaplaningHigher is better | 4th / 10 | 14.5 ft/s² | -1.3 ft/s² |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 3rd / 10 | 80 ft | +2 ft |
| Snow TractionHigher is better | 2nd / 10 | 785 lbf | -6 lbf |
| Snow HandlingHigher is better | 2nd / 10 | 27.0 mph | -0.1 mph |
| NoiseLower is better | 5th / 10 | 72.5 dB | +1.70 dB |
| Rolling ResistanceLower is better | 1st / 10 | 7.11 kg/t | Best in this discipline |
- EU Label
- B/B/71
- Price
- 580.00
Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen 3 SUV
215/65 R17 99VCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (11)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 7th / 10 | 141 ft | +16 ft |
| Dry HandlingHigher is better | 6th / 10 | 64.9 mph | -0.7 mph |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 3rd / 10 | 164 ft | +6 ft |
| Wet HandlingHigher is better | 5th / 10 | 40.2 mph | -0.9 mph |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 1st / 10 | 53.9 mph | Best in this discipline |
| Curved AquaplaningHigher is better | 5th / 10 | 14.4 ft/s² | -1.4 ft/s² |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 8th / 10 | 82 ft | +4 ft |
| Snow TractionHigher is better | 7th / 10 | 751 lbf | -40 lbf |
| Snow HandlingHigher is better | 5th / 10 | 26.5 mph | -0.6 mph |
| NoiseLower is better | 3rd / 10 | 72.2 dB | +1.40 dB |
| Rolling ResistanceLower is better | 7th / 10 | 7.93 kg/t | +0.82 kg/t |
- EU Label
- C/B/72
- Price
- 515.00
Continental AllSeasonContact
215/65 R17 99VCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (11)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 10th / 10 | 143 ft | +18 ft |
| Dry HandlingHigher is better | 7th / 10 | 64.7 mph | -0.9 mph |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 1st / 10 | 158 ft | Best in this discipline |
| Wet HandlingHigher is better | 3rd / 10 | 40.7 mph | -0.4 mph |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 2nd / 10 | 53.4 mph | -0.5 mph |
| Curved AquaplaningHigher is better | 2nd / 10 | 15.7 ft/s² | -0.1 ft/s² |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 2nd / 10 | 78 ft | 0 ft |
| Snow TractionHigher is better | 3rd / 10 | 784 lbf | -7 lbf |
| Snow HandlingHigher is better | 2nd / 10 | 27.0 mph | -0.1 mph |
| NoiseLower is better | 7th / 10 | 72.7 dB | +1.90 dB |
| Rolling ResistanceLower is better | 2nd / 10 | 7.2 kg/t | +0.09 kg/t |
- EU Label
- B/B/72
- Price
- 545.00
Bridgestone Weather Control A005 EVO
215/65 R17 103V XLCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (11)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 8th / 10 | 142 ft | +17 ft |
| Dry HandlingHigher is better | 4th / 10 | 65.1 mph | -0.5 mph |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 5th / 10 | 166 ft | +8 ft |
| Wet HandlingHigher is better | 2nd / 10 | 40.8 mph | -0.3 mph |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 4th / 10 | 51.9 mph | -2.0 mph |
| Curved AquaplaningHigher is better | 6th / 10 | 13.1 ft/s² | -2.7 ft/s² |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 5th / 10 | 81 ft | +3 ft |
| Snow TractionHigher is better | 5th / 10 | 774 lbf | -17 lbf |
| Snow HandlingHigher is better | 7th / 10 | 26.3 mph | -0.8 mph |
| NoiseLower is better | 6th / 10 | 72.6 dB | +1.80 dB |
| Rolling ResistanceLower is better | 4th / 10 | 7.86 kg/t | +0.75 kg/t |
- EU Label
- C/A/71
- Price
- 520.00
Vredestein Quatrac Pro
215/65 R17 99VCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (11)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 5th / 10 | 137 ft | +12 ft |
| Dry HandlingHigher is better | 2nd / 10 | 65.4 mph | -0.2 mph |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 2nd / 10 | 159 ft | +1 ft |
| Wet HandlingHigher is better | 1st / 10 | 41.1 mph | Best in this discipline |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 10th / 10 | 46.6 mph | -7.3 mph |
| Curved AquaplaningHigher is better | 7th / 10 | 13.0 ft/s² | -2.8 ft/s² |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 9th / 10 | 82 ft | +4 ft |
| Snow TractionHigher is better | 9th / 10 | 714 lbf | -77 lbf |
| Snow HandlingHigher is better | 8th / 10 | 26.3 mph | -0.8 mph |
| NoiseLower is better | 10th / 10 | 73.8 dB | +3.00 dB |
| Rolling ResistanceLower is better | 5th / 10 | 7.88 kg/t | +0.77 kg/t |
- EU Label
- C/B/71
- Price
- 510.00
Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF2
215/65 R17 103V XLCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (11)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 2nd / 10 | 132 ft | +7 ft |
| Dry HandlingHigher is better | 9th / 10 | 64.4 mph | -1.2 mph |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 8th / 10 | 174 ft | +16 ft |
| Wet HandlingHigher is better | 6th / 10 | 39.8 mph | -1.3 mph |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 5th / 10 | 51.9 mph | -2.0 mph |
| Curved AquaplaningHigher is better | 8th / 10 | 12.6 ft/s² | -3.2 ft/s² |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 4th / 10 | 80 ft | +2 ft |
| Snow TractionHigher is better | 4th / 10 | 782 lbf | -9 lbf |
| Snow HandlingHigher is better | 4th / 10 | 26.7 mph | -0.4 mph |
| NoiseLower is better | 1st / 10 | 70.8 dB | Best in this discipline |
| Rolling ResistanceLower is better | 3rd / 10 | 7.32 kg/t | +0.21 kg/t |
- EU Label
- B/B/69
- Price
- 440.00
Maxxis Premitra All Season AP3 SUV
215/65 R17 103V XLCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (11)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 3rd / 10 | 133 ft | +8 ft |
| Dry HandlingHigher is better | 5th / 10 | 65.0 mph | -0.6 mph |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 9th / 10 | 177 ft | +19 ft |
| Wet HandlingHigher is better | 7th / 10 | 39.5 mph | -1.6 mph |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 7th / 10 | 50.6 mph | -3.3 mph |
| Curved AquaplaningHigher is better | 9th / 10 | 12.3 ft/s² | -3.5 ft/s² |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 5th / 10 | 81 ft | +3 ft |
| Snow TractionHigher is better | 6th / 10 | 759 lbf | -32 lbf |
| Snow HandlingHigher is better | 6th / 10 | 26.4 mph | -0.7 mph |
| NoiseLower is better | 7th / 10 | 72.7 dB | +1.90 dB |
| Rolling ResistanceLower is better | 9th / 10 | 8.39 kg/t | +1.28 kg/t |
- EU Label
- B/B/72
- Price
- 395.00
Cooper Discoverer All Season
215/65 R17 99VCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (11)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 4th / 10 | 134 ft | +9 ft |
| Dry HandlingHigher is better | 8th / 10 | 64.7 mph | -0.9 mph |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 6th / 10 | 167 ft | +9 ft |
| Wet HandlingHigher is better | 9th / 10 | 39.0 mph | -2.1 mph |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 3rd / 10 | 53.1 mph | -0.8 mph |
| Curved AquaplaningHigher is better | 1st / 10 | 15.8 ft/s² | Best in this discipline |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 5th / 10 | 81 ft | +3 ft |
| Snow TractionHigher is better | 8th / 10 | 726 lbf | -65 lbf |
| Snow HandlingHigher is better | 9th / 10 | 26.1 mph | -1.0 mph |
| NoiseLower is better | 4th / 10 | 72.4 dB | +1.60 dB |
| Rolling ResistanceLower is better | 10th / 10 | 9.32 kg/t | +2.21 kg/t |
- EU Label
- D/B/70
- Price
- 365.00
Imperial All Season Driver
215/65 R17 99VCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (11)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 9th / 10 | 142 ft | +17 ft |
| Dry HandlingHigher is better | 9th / 10 | 64.4 mph | -1.2 mph |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 10th / 10 | 199 ft | +41 ft |
| Wet HandlingHigher is better | 10th / 10 | 38.1 mph | -3.0 mph |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 9th / 10 | 47.7 mph | -6.2 mph |
| Curved AquaplaningHigher is better | 10th / 10 | 11.6 ft/s² | -4.2 ft/s² |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 10th / 10 | 83 ft | +5 ft |
| Snow TractionHigher is better | 10th / 10 | 711 lbf | -80 lbf |
| Snow HandlingHigher is better | 10th / 10 | 25.7 mph | -1.4 mph |
| NoiseLower is better | 9th / 10 | 73.5 dB | +2.70 dB |
| Rolling ResistanceLower is better | 8th / 10 | 8.01 kg/t | +0.90 kg/t |
- EU Label
- C/B/71
- Price
- 295.00


Late to the party but hunting for new tires for an X3M40. Was going to fit high performance summers again but toying Cross Climate 2. It doesn't look as if I'm trading much dry/wet performance for a chunk of winter performance gain. It's a family wagon so doesn't often get driven with enthusiasm, am I nuts to be thinking all season?
Not nuts, though with that much weight and power maybe the all season tire would be more noticable! Though the CC2 is OE on the new Volvo electric SUV.