74%
- Subaru Forester sti
- 225/45 R17 H
- 15,700 miles
- Mostly Motorways
- Average
The Tire creek after 25000Km
Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2 Owner Reviews
Review this tireWhat owners say summarised from 366 reviews
Across driver feedback, the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2 is widely praised as a confidence-inspiring UHP summer tire with standout wet grip, strong dry grip/braking, and a noticeably quieter, more comfortable ride than many OEM-fit rivals (especially when replacing run-flats). Many owners also highlight stable high-speed manners, predictable breakaway, and reduced tramlining. The most consistent drawbacks are faster-than-expected wear for some drivers and a softer sidewall feel that can reduce steering sharpness, with a notable subset also reporting sidewall bulges/damage sensitivity on rough, pothole-prone roads (particularly with run-flat fitments).
What owners mention most counted across 353 reviews
Tap one to read only the reviews that mention it.
Owner ratings averaged from 411 ratings
- Owner score 86%
- Dry Grip 91%
- Wet Grip 89%
- Comfort 87%
- Road Feedback 86%
- Handling 85%
- Wear 80%
Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2 Reviews - Page 19
Score spread across 364 written reviews
90%
- Volkswagen Golf GTI
- 225/45 R17 W
- 25,000 miles
- A Combination of Roads
- Average
Very good tire for all conditions. Tested on my golf v 280ps.
Very good on wet. No fast wearing , not very noisy. Wanted a little more grippy at dry.
Very good on wet. No fast wearing , not very noisy. Wanted a little more grippy at dry.
Check out how the BEST all seasons tires perform against premium summer and winter tires!
93%
- BMW 530dA M sport Touring
- 235/45 R17 W
- 15,000 miles
- Mostly Motorways
- Average
25000 kilometers and only slight wear on the rears, fronts are OK. Mainly motorways. The car feels much stable in the corners. Will buy again!
Which tires do you drive?
Researching the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2? Rate the tires you actually drive - and help the next buyer choose.
100%
- BMW 320i
- 225/45 R17
- 10,000 miles
- A Combination of Roads
- Average
great tire great grip great handling great low noise.. its just grrreeeaaaat haha sounds like a frosties advert
90%
- Honda S2000
- 225/45 R17
- 2,000 miles
- Mostly Town
- Spirited
Best tires for my s2000. The car was shaky in the wet and these tires really helped with oversteer. Would highly recommend and I'll be getting these again for sure.
99%
- Volkswagen GOLF MK5 R32 3.2 V6 4MOTION
- 225/45 R17 W
- 25,000 miles
- A Combination of Roads
- Spirited
Put these on my R32 after reading comments on here !
Boy they transformed the car !
The ride was so quiet and comfy, but wow did they change the handling, stuck like glue
Brilliant tire in all weathers - just wish they did them for my bmw 520d m sport in run flat !
doesn't handle like the R32 0 but is far more economical on juice - but not as much fun to drive !
Boy they transformed the car !
The ride was so quiet and comfy, but wow did they change the handling, stuck like glue
Brilliant tire in all weathers - just wish they did them for my bmw 520d m sport in run flat !
doesn't handle like the R32 0 but is far more economical on juice - but not as much fun to drive !
91%
- Audi A3 Sportback
- 225/40 R18 W
- 12,000 miles
- Mostly Motorways
- Average
Excellent all round tire, I used to use Michelin pilot sport 3's which did have better dry grip but they wore quite quickly. The Goodyear is better in the wet, just as good in the dry and lasts longer. Oh and cheaper. Will buy again
68%
- Honda Accord
- 235/45 R18 W
- 1,000 miles
- A Combination of Roads
- Average
Dry Grip: 9/10. Excellent grip for high-speed sharp cornering and braking at 160KM/H
Wet Grip: 8/10. Grips very well too during cornering and sudden hard braking. 160KM/H
Wear: NA. Could not tell much right now.
Comfort: 5/10. Tires is a bit hard, rough and bumpy. At 100km/h, I hardly heard tires noise when tires are new, but the noise become more noticeable after clocking 1000KM. Noise is louder as you go faster. Im am quite disappointed at this.
Buy again: 50 50. It's not the right tires if you're emphasizing more on comfort.
Note: 4 new tires 235/45/R18 fitted on Honda Accord 2010, clocking 1,000 KMS already.
Wet Grip: 8/10. Grips very well too during cornering and sudden hard braking. 160KM/H
Wear: NA. Could not tell much right now.
Comfort: 5/10. Tires is a bit hard, rough and bumpy. At 100km/h, I hardly heard tires noise when tires are new, but the noise become more noticeable after clocking 1000KM. Noise is louder as you go faster. Im am quite disappointed at this.
Buy again: 50 50. It's not the right tires if you're emphasizing more on comfort.
Note: 4 new tires 235/45/R18 fitted on Honda Accord 2010, clocking 1,000 KMS already.
77%
- Vauxhall Astra 1.9 cdti 150hp
- 225/40 R18 W
- 4,000 miles
- Mostly Country Roads
- Spirited
Had my fair share of tires and I went with these after reading all the good reviews.
Personally thought they weren't as good as my Khumo's and I've heard the GSD3's are better than the A2's.
But they are a good tire... Just think there's maybe better.
They lasted 4000 miles putting 340lbs of torque down... Which is pretty good considering I drive it like I've stole it!
Car has DAP R springs with Bilstien B8 shocks and a whiteline RARB.
These are safe option to go for... And I would get them again.
Personally thought they weren't as good as my Khumo's and I've heard the GSD3's are better than the A2's.
But they are a good tire... Just think there's maybe better.
They lasted 4000 miles putting 340lbs of torque down... Which is pretty good considering I drive it like I've stole it!
Car has DAP R springs with Bilstien B8 shocks and a whiteline RARB.
These are safe option to go for... And I would get them again.
91%
- Ford Focus ST
- 225/40 R18
- 8,000 miles
- A Combination of Roads
- Spirited
Fitted to Focus ST and simply brilliant. My ST has 230bhp through the front wheels and no traction control so represents a major challenge for a tire. Some torque steer and occasional scrabbling is inevitable but these babies grip like hell. I've also never experienced a tire which grips and brakes so well in the wet, quite incredible. So much so, that I've lost the back end twice(1 pirreli and 1 dunlop, but well past their best)when cornering on a greasy surface - this from a car which you might normally expect to put its nose out first. Feedback is also notably excellent.8000 miles nad still life in them, despite my very heavy right foot.
51%
- Alfa Romeo MiTo
- 215/45 R17 W
- 2,000 miles
- A Combination of Roads
- Average
I have to admit I was fooled by the good reviews and chose them. They are definitely not sport tires, by the feel they have. At the beginning I thought its me and the new feel of a brand new set of tires comparing to my old ones that were "burned". But no. I tried to adjust pressure but nothing. Whatever I did, they giving the same feeling like driving on balloons. I thought they are brand new, after some hundreds of km might be better but still nothing. I started to suspend even my absorbers but I am persuaded that its only the tires.
Good grip, good comfort, but the sides are like butter and they folding easily. Very disappointed. My previous Continental SC3 were way much better than those.
Good grip, good comfort, but the sides are like butter and they folding easily. Very disappointed. My previous Continental SC3 were way much better than those.
93%
- SEAT LEON 1.8TSI
- 225/45 R17 W
- 13 miles
- A Combination of Roads
- Spirited
I own a FF car which currently has 230hp and max torque of 345Nm. After 20.000 km on these tires, I really can't say anything negative for them. I was shocked by the level of grip in the wet - light years in front of other similar tires. Same applies to the grip level in the dry - Of course I wasn't shocked but I was really satisfied overall.
Noise level is far lower than anything else I have ever used. In terms of progressiveness, the tires are safe. The offer you enough time between limit and loss of grip. Probably the best performance tire in the market right now.
Would definitely buy them again - No question about it.
Noise level is far lower than anything else I have ever used. In terms of progressiveness, the tires are safe. The offer you enough time between limit and loss of grip. Probably the best performance tire in the market right now.
Would definitely buy them again - No question about it.
No reviews match those filters.
Find your next tire
All tire testsThe latest Tire Reviews tests
- Oct 2026The BEST All Weather Tires for 2026/27 →
- Oct 2026All Season vs All Terrain Tires Tested: Do You Actually Need an All Terrain? →
- Oct 2026The BEST Winter Tires for 2026/27 →
Summer Tires
All Season Tires
Winter Tires
SUV and All Terrain Tires
Track Tires
Which tires do you drive?
You're reading real-world reviews from other drivers - add yours and help the next buyer choose the right tires.