## Michelin Primacy 5 Energy — update after one season
I bought the Michelin Primacy 5 Energy tires on 20 May 2026 and fitted them a few days later. After one summer season and approximately 10,000 km, I can give a more balanced opinion than in my initial review, written just a week after fitting them.
My VW ID.3 Pro (204 HP, 310 Nm, rear-wheel drive) is fitted with 215/55 R18 99V XL tires with rim protection.
Handling and stability remain the biggest advantages. Compared with the factory weird Continental EcoContact 6 (95T), the Michelins make the car feel much more planted and predictable. The stiffer sidewalls are a major improvement over the original tires, which made the car feel rather soft and boat-like.
I also tested them in the mountains on wet asphalt, in cold and rainy conditions, including tight hairpin bends. I deliberately tried to break traction, and although it was possible, I had to push the car quite hard. When traction was finally lost, it was only briefly. This gave me a positive impression of their wet grip and predictability, although it wasn't a controlled test.
Energy consumption is another significant advantage. Compared with the original Continental EcoContact 6, I've observed a reduction of around 1–2 kWh/100 km — a meaningful difference for an EV.
Noise is where I have to revise my initial opinion. Despite their official external noise rating of 69 dB, I expected them to be quieter inside the cabin. They aren't excessively noisy, but road noise is more noticeable than I had hoped.
My expectations probably come from previous experience. The quietest summer tires I've ever owned were Dunlop Sport BluResponse, which I used around 2015. They were exceptionally quiet and comfortable, although I remember them wearing relatively quickly. Of course, comparing tires across different cars and wheel sizes isn't entirely fair.
The noise level isn't a deal-breaker. Considering the improvement in handling, stability and energy consumption, I'm still happy with my choice.
And one small detail still makes me smile: the clear Michelin branding and the little Michelin Man raising his hand as if greeting me whenever I walk up to the car. A small thing, perhaps, but it genuinely improves my mood.
Overall: After one season and approximately 10,000 km+, I still consider the Michelin Primacy 5 Energy 99V XL a significant upgrade over the factory Continental EcoContact 6. Excellent stability, reassuring wet grip and lower energy consumption make them a very good choice for my needs. I just expected them to be quieter inside the cabin.
Tire Reviews Replies
