68%
- Honda FRV
- 225/45 R17
- A Combination of Roads
- Average
Sidewall to soft , all ways look flat, a lot of road noise not comfortable
Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2 Owner Reviews
Review this tireWhat owners say summarised from 366 reviews
Across driver feedback, the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2 is widely praised as a confidence-inspiring UHP summer tire with standout wet grip, strong dry grip/braking, and a noticeably quieter, more comfortable ride than many OEM-fit rivals (especially when replacing run-flats). Many owners also highlight stable high-speed manners, predictable breakaway, and reduced tramlining. The most consistent drawbacks are faster-than-expected wear for some drivers and a softer sidewall feel that can reduce steering sharpness, with a notable subset also reporting sidewall bulges/damage sensitivity on rough, pothole-prone roads (particularly with run-flat fitments).
What owners mention most counted across 353 reviews
Tap one to read only the reviews that mention it.
Owner ratings averaged from 411 ratings
- Owner score 86%
- Dry Grip 91%
- Wet Grip 89%
- Comfort 87%
- Road Feedback 86%
- Handling 85%
- Wear 80%
Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2 Reviews - Page 11
Score spread across 364 written reviews
100%
- Audi TT
- 225/40 R18 W
- 500 miles
- A Combination of Roads
- Average
Recently fitted to my 225Bhp TT Quattro and What a transformation to the Avon crap that was previously on the car. Loads quieter, 5 mpg improvement and fully optimizes the Quattro. These are a must have tire for any performance car! I've not had them long, but the difference is immediate and was recommended by a friend. Great independent reviews for this tire. Good value at £93.00 each, fully fitted price for 225/40/18/Y.
Check out how the BEST all seasons tires perform against premium summer and winter tires!
53%
- Audi A5
- 255/35 R19 W
- 7,000 miles
- Mostly Town
- Average
Good tires however on lasted 7000 miles over the summer from new and that's normal driving. Come winter the winter tires go on. Previous to the goodyears we had continental sport 5ps which lasted two summers and about 15000 miles. So its March again its time to get some new tires. Had goodyear and continental so its time to try Michelin pilot super sports which I will report back on later in the year. The goodyears are a comfortable and decent tire but the wear rate is only let down.
Which tires do you drive?
Researching the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2? Rate the tires you actually drive - and help the next buyer choose.
100%
- BMW Z4 3.0
- 255/30 R19 W
- 150 miles
- A Combination of Roads
- Average
ok ive only had these tires for 150miles or so, however that being said, from the moment i left the forecourt of the garage, the difference in comfort alone compared to my stock Potenza's has been immense!
shocks from potholes, old road works, country roads reduced significantly,
road noise reduced 10 out of 10
vibrations in car reduced 10 out of 10
handling improved simply by the feeling your not bouncing in and out of potholes etc. but actually hugging the road 10 out of 10
i still have Potenza RFTs on the front so tramlining has increased, however, once i have tin, the fronts will be replaced.
dry grip 10 out of 10
wet grip only had a couple of showers so far, but feel good, i will update this again when i experienced some really wet weather.
i will update again once ive covered more miles, replaced the fronts, and driven in the wet....
im struggling for negatives to balance this review..im liking these eagles alot!
shocks from potholes, old road works, country roads reduced significantly,
road noise reduced 10 out of 10
vibrations in car reduced 10 out of 10
handling improved simply by the feeling your not bouncing in and out of potholes etc. but actually hugging the road 10 out of 10
i still have Potenza RFTs on the front so tramlining has increased, however, once i have tin, the fronts will be replaced.
dry grip 10 out of 10
wet grip only had a couple of showers so far, but feel good, i will update this again when i experienced some really wet weather.
i will update again once ive covered more miles, replaced the fronts, and driven in the wet....
im struggling for negatives to balance this review..im liking these eagles alot!
99%
- Audi ALLROAD 2.5 TDI
- 245/45 R18 W
- 20,000 miles
- A Combination of Roads
- Average
Very reliable and comfortable tire...
52%
- Vauxhall Astra SRi
- 225/40 R18 W
- 1,000 miles
- A Combination of Roads
- Spirited
Really disappointed in these tires! I had Continental CS5's on before and they were fantastic in the wet and the dry, driving on the limit, and lasted 30k miles hard driving! These by comparison are awful. At first I thought maybe it was the cold weather but even now it's warmed up and on dry roads the grip is very poor! I had so much confidence on the CS5's, I could go into corners flat out knowing the grip would be there, right from day 1 till I changed them. These tires give terrible understear, spin up on acceleration, even on the dry. Feel softer and don't offer the sure footed feeling the CS5's gave. So wish I'd bought the Contis again, I nearly did, they were slightly cheaper too. Can't believe it with the reviews on hee, which is why I went for these. Are people just being sheep with their reviews or are they just Sunday drivers??? Gutted! Now I have at least a couple of years to put up with this lack of grip! Baahhhhh :'(
57%
- BMW 330d M Sport
- 225/45 R17
- 2,000 miles
- A Combination of Roads
- Spirited
I replaced runflat tires with Goodyear Eagle F1 Asy2 - 255/35/18 on the rear and 225/4/18 front. BMW 330d MSport
Hindsight is a great thing - people slag off runflats as harsh, uncomfortable, noisy, tramlining etc but it's noticeable how inferior the Goodyears are to the Pirelli PZero runflats.
I got 30k miles out of the Pirellis, great feedback, instant and rock steady turn in. The fronts were at 3mm and the rears at the legal limit after this mileage. The Goodyears are washy and imprecise in comparison. Yes the ride is more supple but I don't get anywhere near the precise feel of the Pirelli. I chose the Eagles because everyone raves about them and says BMWs are great off runflats - maybe that's Bridgestones they complain about because the Pirelli runflats are a much better tire. The Pirelli only started to tramline significantly when they got to the legal limit.
Anyone want to buy some nearly new Goodyears?
Hindsight is a great thing - people slag off runflats as harsh, uncomfortable, noisy, tramlining etc but it's noticeable how inferior the Goodyears are to the Pirelli PZero runflats.
I got 30k miles out of the Pirellis, great feedback, instant and rock steady turn in. The fronts were at 3mm and the rears at the legal limit after this mileage. The Goodyears are washy and imprecise in comparison. Yes the ride is more supple but I don't get anywhere near the precise feel of the Pirelli. I chose the Eagles because everyone raves about them and says BMWs are great off runflats - maybe that's Bridgestones they complain about because the Pirelli runflats are a much better tire. The Pirelli only started to tramline significantly when they got to the legal limit.
Anyone want to buy some nearly new Goodyears?
100%
- Audi A3 TDI SLine Quattro 181bhp
- 225/45 R17
- 26,000 miles
- A Combination of Roads
- Spirited
I fitted these tires in 225/40/18/y spec to my new shape 2013 Audi A3 TDI quattro 181bhp which has been chipped up to 230bhp. the stock tires were Contintental Sportcontact 3 - which I found were loud on many surfaces and in the wet completely unpredictable. these tires lasted to 16,000 and returned about 42mpg.
I have now done 10k on the Eagle F1 assymetric 2's and have noticed a not insignificant rise to 46mpg and can say without a doubt on pothole and uneven roads the supple, compliant and confidence inspriring feel of this tire has turned an already confident car into an absolute dream! hands down if you have an Audi Quattro (2013 onward) this is definitely the only tire you will ever want to be considering placing on your vehicle. i dont know about other cars but for the A3 this tire absolutely nails it and suits the character of the car.
I have now done 10k on the Eagle F1 assymetric 2's and have noticed a not insignificant rise to 46mpg and can say without a doubt on pothole and uneven roads the supple, compliant and confidence inspriring feel of this tire has turned an already confident car into an absolute dream! hands down if you have an Audi Quattro (2013 onward) this is definitely the only tire you will ever want to be considering placing on your vehicle. i dont know about other cars but for the A3 this tire absolutely nails it and suits the character of the car.
86%
- Ford Focus RS Mk1
- 225/45 R17
- 8,000 miles
- Mostly Town
- Spirited
I'm not sure if the isometric 1s were slightly better than the 2s. I tried Michelin sport3 and would say the f1s were better I wore the Michelins out in 4 months on the front but drive hard. The f1s were definitely better in the wet which matters in England. Back to f1 eagle for me.
93%
- Mazda Mazda3 MPS Aero
- 225/40 R18
- 50,000 miles
- A Combination of Roads
- Spirited
Superb tire. Had 4 fitted - the fronts lasted 25k miles of mixed driving, the rears nearly 50k.
Huge grip in all weathers, fantastic directional stability, very positive just off center. The only downsides were the sidewalls were very stiff, which affected the ride quality. I'd have them again, if only they made them in my new cars size!
Huge grip in all weathers, fantastic directional stability, very positive just off center. The only downsides were the sidewalls were very stiff, which affected the ride quality. I'd have them again, if only they made them in my new cars size!
83%
- Audi
- 225/45 R17
- 25,000 miles
- A Combination of Roads
- Spirited
I put these on my FWD A3 (sportback) 2.0T (mapped to 240bhp\250ft\lb) and have covered 12'000 miles on the front and 24'000 at the back. Noise is noticeable when the tread gets low, but that's the same for all tires. The wet grip is better than any Summer tire I've used in 35 years of driving and they inspire confidence in all conditions. Dry grip is also exceptional. Longevity is slightly disappointing at the front, but not so much as to prevent me buying again, because I can't find another set of all-rounders that perform this well in the wet and dry, right down to 3/4oC.
93%
- Audi
- 255/35 R19
- 7,000 miles
- Mostly Motorways
- Spirited
Great tires so much better then the Dunlops that cam eon my car
No reviews match those filters.
Find your next tire
All tire testsThe latest Tire Reviews tests
- Oct 2026The BEST All Weather Tires for 2026/27 →
- Oct 2026All Season vs All Terrain Tires Tested: Do You Actually Need an All Terrain? →
- Oct 2026The BEST Winter Tires for 2026/27 →
Summer Tires
All Season Tires
Winter Tires
SUV and All Terrain Tires
Track Tires
Which tires do you drive?
You're reading real-world reviews from other drivers - add yours and help the next buyer choose the right tires.