The excellent magazine Vi Bilagare tested seven studded tires and one friction (non-studded) winter tire - the Nokian Hakkapeliitta R5. Testing was conducted in various locations across Finland and Sweden, using a Volkswagen Golf for most tests.
Test setup & methodology
The test setting, the conditions recorded and how the results contribute to the score.
Recorded test conditions
Recorded test conditions
- Dry Braking
- 49.7 → 3.1 mph · 54–59 °F
- Subj. Dry Handling
- 57–63 °F
- Wet Braking
- 49.7 → 3.1 mph · 54–57 °F
- Wet Handling
- 45–48 °F
- Snow Braking
- 21.7 → 3.1 mph · 21–25 °F
- Snow Traction
- 3.1 → 21.7 mph · 21–25 °F
- Snow Handling
- 10–12 °F
- Ice Braking
- 15.5 → 3.1 mph · 21–23 °F
- Ice Traction
- 3.1 → 15.5 mph · 21–23 °F
- Ice Handling
- 5–10 °F
Friction vs Studded Performance
The Nokian Hakkapeliitta R5 friction tire showed some interesting characteristics. On rough ice and snow, it matched or exceeded the studded tires for cornering grip. However, on polished ice, it struggled significantly with braking and acceleration, performing similarly to the budget Mazzini studded tire. The friction tire excelled in comfort aspects, with the lowest noise levels and best fuel economy, but showed clear weaknesses in wet grip and early aquaplaning.
Budget Tire Performance
The Chinese-made Mazzini Ice Leopard highlighted the performance gap between premium and budget tires. While it showed decent performance on dry and wet asphalt, it struggled in winter conditions. Its ice grip was poor, with sudden loss of cornering grip occurring without warning. Even with studs, it couldn't outperform the friction tire on polished ice.
Other Points
The magazine noted that production changes due to leaving Russia have affected quality control, with both Michelin and Bridgestone showing inconsistent stud mounting, the Bridgestone had significant stud retention issues during testing, losing 26 studs from the front tires, and that the Continental showed unusual characteristics for a studded tire, with ice performance being its weakest point but excellent wet and dry road handling.
Dry
Dry Braking
Dry Braking
Dry braking in feet (50 - 3 mph) [Average Temperature 56°F]
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best | Residual speed |
|---|---|---|---|
| 103 ft | Best | 0 mph | |
| 106 ft | +3 ft | 12 mph | |
| 107 ft | +4 ft | 14 mph | |
| 107 ft | +4 ft | 15 mph | |
| 109 ft | +6 ft | 18 mph | |
| 109 ft | +6 ft | 18 mph | |
| 110 ft | +7 ft | 20 mph | |
| 112 ft | +9 ft | 22 mph |
The difference between best and worst was 8.3% (9 ft ≈ 0.6 Car Lengths). From 80 mph, the Bridgestone Blizzak Spike 3 would still be travelling at 22 mph when the Nokian Hakkapeliitta R5 had stopped.
Residual speed is calculated from the measured braking distances, assuming constant deceleration; it is not a separate measurement.
Subj. Dry Handling
Subj. Dry Handling
Subjective Dry Handling Score [Average Temperature 60°F]
Higher is better ↑| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
| 5 Points | Best | |
| 5 Points | Best | |
| 4 Points | -1.00 Points | |
| 3 Points | -2.00 Points | |
| 3 Points | -2.00 Points | |
| 3 Points | -2.00 Points | |
| 3 Points | -2.00 Points | |
| 2 Points | -3.00 Points |
The difference between best and worst was 60% (3 Points).
Wet
Wet Braking
Wet Braking
Wet braking in feet (50 - 3 mph) [Average Temperature 55°F]
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best | Residual speed |
|---|---|---|---|
| 113 ft | Best | 0 mph | |
| 114 ft | +1 ft | 9 mph | |
| 116 ft | +3 ft | 14 mph | |
| 116 ft | +3 ft | 14 mph | |
| 119 ft | +6 ft | 19 mph | |
| 122 ft | +9 ft | 22 mph | |
| 122 ft | +9 ft | 23 mph | |
| 126 ft | +13 ft | 26 mph |
The difference between best and worst was 11.9% (13 ft ≈ 0.9 Car Lengths). From 80 mph, the Nokian Hakkapeliitta R5 would still be travelling at 26 mph when the Mazzini Ice Leopard had stopped.
Residual speed is calculated from the measured braking distances, assuming constant deceleration; it is not a separate measurement.
Wet Handling
Wet Handling
Wet handling time in seconds [Average Temperature 46°F]
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
| 40.7 s | Best | |
| 41.4 s | +0.70 s | |
| 41.5 s | +0.80 s | |
| 41.7 s | +1.00 s | |
| 41.9 s | +1.20 s | |
| 41.9 s | +1.20 s | |
| 41.9 s | +1.20 s | |
| 42.1 s | +1.40 s |
The difference between best and worst was 3.4% (1.4 s).
Straight Aqua
Straight Aqua
Float Speed in mph
Higher is better ↑| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
| 46.0 mph | Best | |
| 44.2 mph | -1.8 mph | |
| 43.9 mph | -2.1 mph | |
| 43.0 mph | -3.0 mph | |
| 42.4 mph | -3.6 mph | |
| 42.4 mph | -3.6 mph | |
| 39.1 mph | -6.9 mph | |
| 36.4 mph | -9.6 mph |
The difference between best and worst was 20.8% (9.6 mph).
Snow
Snow Braking
Snow Braking
Snow braking in feet (22 - 3 mph) [Average Temperature 23°F]
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best | Residual speed |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40 ft | Best | 0 mph | |
| 40 ft | 0 ft | 4 mph | |
| 41 ft | +1 ft | 7 mph | |
| 41 ft | +1 ft | 7 mph | |
| 41 ft | +1 ft | 8 mph | |
| 41 ft | +1 ft | 10 mph | |
| 42 ft | +2 ft | 14 mph | |
| 42 ft | +2 ft | 18 mph |
The difference between best and worst was 5.1% (2 ft). From 80 mph, the Mazzini Ice Leopard would still be travelling at 18 mph when the Nordman North 9 had stopped.
Residual speed is calculated from the measured braking distances, assuming constant deceleration; it is not a separate measurement.
Snow Traction
Snow Traction
Snow acceleration time (3 - 22 mph) [Average Temperature 23°F]
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
| 4.1 s | Best | |
| 4.21 s | +0.11 s | |
| 4.24 s | +0.14 s | |
| 4.32 s | +0.22 s | |
| 4.32 s | +0.22 s | |
| 4.35 s | +0.25 s | |
| 4.4 s | +0.30 s | |
| 4.45 s | +0.35 s |
The difference between best and worst was 8.5% (0.35 s).
Snow Handling
Snow Handling
Snow handling time in seconds [Average Temperature 11°F]
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
| 75.1 s | Best | |
| 75.2 s | +0.10 s | |
| 75.6 s | +0.50 s | |
| 75.8 s | +0.70 s | |
| 76.2 s | +1.10 s | |
| 76.4 s | +1.30 s | |
| 77.1 s | +2.00 s | |
| 78 s | +2.90 s |
The difference between best and worst was 3.9% (2.9 s).
Ice
Ice Braking
Ice Braking
Ice braking in feet (16 - 3 mph) [Average Temperature 22°F]
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best | Residual speed |
|---|---|---|---|
| 36 ft | Best | 0 mph | |
| 38 ft | +2 ft | 20 mph | |
| 41 ft | +5 ft | 29 mph | |
| 44 ft | +8 ft | 34 mph | |
| 45 ft | +9 ft | 36 mph | |
| 52 ft | +16 ft | 44 mph | |
| 58 ft | +22 ft | 49 mph | |
| 59 ft | +23 ft | 49 mph |
The difference between best and worst was 62% (23 ft ≈ 1.5 Car Lengths). From 80 mph, the Nokian Hakkapeliitta R5 would still be travelling at 49 mph when the Bridgestone Blizzak Spike 3 had stopped.
Residual speed is calculated from the measured braking distances, assuming constant deceleration; it is not a separate measurement.
Ice Traction
Ice Traction
Ice acceleration time (3 - 16 mph) [Average Temperature 22°F]
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
| 4.61 s | Best | |
| 5.38 s | +0.77 s | |
| 5.55 s | +0.94 s | |
| 5.66 s | +1.05 s | |
| 6.19 s | +1.58 s | |
| 6.81 s | +2.20 s | |
| 7.99 s | +3.38 s | |
| 9.42 s | +4.81 s |
The difference between best and worst was 104.3% (4.81 s).
Ice Handling
Ice Handling
Ice handling time in seconds [Average Temperature 8°F]
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
| 47.8 s | Best | |
| 48 s | +0.20 s | |
| 48.2 s | +0.40 s | |
| 48.4 s | +0.60 s | |
| 48.5 s | +0.70 s | |
| 50.2 s | +2.40 s | |
| 50.7 s | +2.90 s | |
| 52.2 s | +4.40 s |
The difference between best and worst was 9.2% (4.4 s).
Comfort
Noise
Noise
External noise in dB
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
| 71.5 dB | Best | |
| 73.6 dB | +2.10 dB | |
| 74.6 dB | +3.10 dB | |
| 74.8 dB | +3.30 dB | |
| 75.2 dB | +3.70 dB | |
| 75.5 dB | +4.00 dB | |
| 75.6 dB | +4.10 dB | |
| 76.4 dB | +4.90 dB |
The difference between best and worst was 6.9% (4.9 dB).
Value
Fuel Consumption
Fuel Consumption
Fuel consumption in Liters per 100 km
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tire | Result | Gap to best | Extra fuel / year |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5.25 l/100km | Best | $0 | |
| 5.45 l/100km | +0.20 l/100km | $37 | |
| 5.5 l/100km | +0.25 l/100km | $46 | |
| 5.55 l/100km | +0.30 l/100km | $55 | |
| 5.55 l/100km | +0.30 l/100km | $55 | |
| 5.65 l/100km | +0.40 l/100km | $73 | |
| 5.7 l/100km | +0.45 l/100km | $83 | |
| 5.75 l/100km | +0.50 l/100km | $92 |
The difference between best and worst was 9.5% (0.5 l/100km). Over 12,000 miles a year at $3.60/gal, the Continental IceContact 3 uses about 26 gal ($92) more fuel than the Nokian Hakkapeliitta R5.
Adjust the assumptions
Calculated estimates, not additional measurements. Use the controls to explore the assumptions.
Results
Nokian Hakkapeliitta 10
225/45 R17 94T XLCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (13)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 5th / 8 | 109 ft | +6 ft |
| Subj. Dry HandlingHigher is better | 4th / 8 | 3 Points | -2.00 Points |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 6th / 8 | 122 ft | +9 ft |
| Wet HandlingLower is better | 5th / 8 | 41.9 s | +1.20 s |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 7th / 8 | 39.1 mph | -6.9 mph |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 3rd / 8 | 41 ft | +1 ft |
| Snow TractionLower is better | 4th / 8 | 4.32 s | +0.22 s |
| Snow HandlingLower is better | 2nd / 8 | 75.2 s | +0.10 s |
| Ice BrakingLower is better | 2nd / 8 | 38 ft | +2 ft |
| Ice TractionLower is better | 2nd / 8 | 5.38 s | +0.77 s |
| Ice HandlingLower is better | 1st / 8 | 47.8 s | Best in this discipline |
| NoiseLower is better | 6th / 8 | 75.5 dB | +4.00 dB |
| Fuel ConsumptionLower is better | 4th / 8 | 5.55 l/100km | +0.30 l/100km |
- Shore
- 55
- Stud Count
- 216
- 3PMSF
- Yes
- Weight
- 10.9 kgs
- Tread
- 9.1 mm
- Price
- 2402.00
Bridgestone Blizzak Spike 3
225/45 R17 94T XLCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (13)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 8th / 8 | 112 ft | +9 ft |
| Subj. Dry HandlingHigher is better | 3rd / 8 | 4 Points | -1.00 Points |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 4th / 8 | 116 ft | +3 ft |
| Wet HandlingLower is better | 4th / 8 | 41.7 s | +1.00 s |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 1st / 8 | 46.0 mph | Best in this discipline |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 7th / 8 | 42 ft | +2 ft |
| Snow TractionLower is better | 7th / 8 | 4.4 s | +0.30 s |
| Snow HandlingLower is better | 7th / 8 | 77.1 s | +2.00 s |
| Ice BrakingLower is better | 1st / 8 | 36 ft | Best in this discipline |
| Ice TractionLower is better | 1st / 8 | 4.61 s | Best in this discipline |
| Ice HandlingLower is better | 4th / 8 | 48.4 s | +0.60 s |
| NoiseLower is better | 8th / 8 | 76.4 dB | +4.90 dB |
| Fuel ConsumptionLower is better | 4th / 8 | 5.55 l/100km | +0.30 l/100km |
- Shore
- 63
- Stud Count
- 262
- 3PMSF
- Yes
- Weight
- 10.8 kgs
- Tread
- 9.4 mm
- Price
- 2796.00
Michelin X-Ice North 4
225/45 R17 94T XLCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (13)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 6th / 8 | 109 ft | +6 ft |
| Subj. Dry HandlingHigher is better | 1st / 8 | 5 Points | Best in this discipline |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 7th / 8 | 122 ft | +9 ft |
| Wet HandlingLower is better | 8th / 8 | 42.1 s | +1.40 s |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 4th / 8 | 43.0 mph | -3.0 mph |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 5th / 8 | 41 ft | +1 ft |
| Snow TractionLower is better | 2nd / 8 | 4.21 s | +0.11 s |
| Snow HandlingLower is better | 5th / 8 | 76.2 s | +1.10 s |
| Ice BrakingLower is better | 4th / 8 | 44 ft | +8 ft |
| Ice TractionLower is better | 4th / 8 | 5.66 s | +1.05 s |
| Ice HandlingLower is better | 3rd / 8 | 48.2 s | +0.40 s |
| NoiseLower is better | 3rd / 8 | 74.6 dB | +3.10 dB |
| Fuel ConsumptionLower is better | 3rd / 8 | 5.5 l/100km | +0.25 l/100km |
- Shore
- 59
- Stud Count
- 252
- 3PMSF
- Yes
- Weight
- 10.7 kgs
- Tread
- 8.3 mm
- Price
- 2656.00
Goodyear UltraGrip Arctic 2
225/45 R17 94T XLCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (13)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 4th / 8 | 107 ft | +4 ft |
| Subj. Dry HandlingHigher is better | 4th / 8 | 3 Points | -2.00 Points |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 3rd / 8 | 116 ft | +3 ft |
| Wet HandlingLower is better | 3rd / 8 | 41.5 s | +0.80 s |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 3rd / 8 | 43.9 mph | -2.1 mph |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 3rd / 8 | 41 ft | +1 ft |
| Snow TractionLower is better | 3rd / 8 | 4.24 s | +0.14 s |
| Snow HandlingLower is better | 4th / 8 | 75.8 s | +0.70 s |
| Ice BrakingLower is better | 3rd / 8 | 41 ft | +5 ft |
| Ice TractionLower is better | 5th / 8 | 6.19 s | +1.58 s |
| Ice HandlingLower is better | 5th / 8 | 48.5 s | +0.70 s |
| NoiseLower is better | 5th / 8 | 75.2 dB | +3.70 dB |
| Fuel ConsumptionLower is better | 7th / 8 | 5.7 l/100km | +0.45 l/100km |
- Shore
- 60
- Stud Count
- 190
- 3PMSF
- Yes
- Weight
- 11.3 kgs
- Tread
- 9.9 mm
- Price
- 2386.00
Continental IceContact 3
225/45 R17 94T XLCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (13)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 3rd / 8 | 107 ft | +4 ft |
| Subj. Dry HandlingHigher is better | 1st / 8 | 5 Points | Best in this discipline |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 2nd / 8 | 114 ft | +1 ft |
| Wet HandlingLower is better | 1st / 8 | 40.7 s | Best in this discipline |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 5th / 8 | 42.4 mph | -3.6 mph |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 2nd / 8 | 40 ft | 0 ft |
| Snow TractionLower is better | 4th / 8 | 4.32 s | +0.22 s |
| Snow HandlingLower is better | 1st / 8 | 75.1 s | Best in this discipline |
| Ice BrakingLower is better | 6th / 8 | 52 ft | +16 ft |
| Ice TractionLower is better | 6th / 8 | 6.81 s | +2.20 s |
| Ice HandlingLower is better | 6th / 8 | 50.2 s | +2.40 s |
| NoiseLower is better | 2nd / 8 | 73.6 dB | +2.10 dB |
| Fuel ConsumptionLower is better | 8th / 8 | 5.75 l/100km | +0.50 l/100km |
- Shore
- 61
- Stud Count
- 190
- 3PMSF
- Yes
- Weight
- 10.9 kgs
- Tread
- 8.4 mm
- Price
- 2689.00
Nordman North 9
225/45 R17 94T XLCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (13)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 7th / 8 | 110 ft | +7 ft |
| Subj. Dry HandlingHigher is better | 4th / 8 | 3 Points | -2.00 Points |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 5th / 8 | 119 ft | +6 ft |
| Wet HandlingLower is better | 5th / 8 | 41.9 s | +1.20 s |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 6th / 8 | 42.4 mph | -3.6 mph |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 1st / 8 | 40 ft | Best in this discipline |
| Snow TractionLower is better | 6th / 8 | 4.35 s | +0.25 s |
| Snow HandlingLower is better | 6th / 8 | 76.4 s | +1.30 s |
| Ice BrakingLower is better | 5th / 8 | 45 ft | +9 ft |
| Ice TractionLower is better | 3rd / 8 | 5.55 s | +0.94 s |
| Ice HandlingLower is better | 7th / 8 | 50.7 s | +2.90 s |
| NoiseLower is better | 7th / 8 | 75.6 dB | +4.10 dB |
| Fuel ConsumptionLower is better | 2nd / 8 | 5.45 l/100km | +0.20 l/100km |
- Shore
- 57
- Stud Count
- 196
- 3PMSF
- Yes
- Weight
- 10.3 kgs
- Tread
- 9 mm
- Price
- 1991.00
Nokian Hakkapeliitta R5
225/45 R17 94T XLCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (13)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 1st / 8 | 103 ft | Best in this discipline |
| Subj. Dry HandlingHigher is better | 8th / 8 | 2 Points | -3.00 Points |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 8th / 8 | 126 ft | +13 ft |
| Wet HandlingLower is better | 5th / 8 | 41.9 s | +1.20 s |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 8th / 8 | 36.4 mph | -9.6 mph |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 6th / 8 | 41 ft | +1 ft |
| Snow TractionLower is better | 1st / 8 | 4.1 s | Best in this discipline |
| Snow HandlingLower is better | 3rd / 8 | 75.6 s | +0.50 s |
| Ice BrakingLower is better | 8th / 8 | 59 ft | +23 ft |
| Ice TractionLower is better | 8th / 8 | 9.42 s | +4.81 s |
| Ice HandlingLower is better | 2nd / 8 | 48 s | +0.20 s |
| NoiseLower is better | 1st / 8 | 71.5 dB | Best in this discipline |
| Fuel ConsumptionLower is better | 1st / 8 | 5.25 l/100km | Best in this discipline |
- Shore
- 52
- 3PMSF
- Yes
- Weight
- 9.6 kgs
- Tread
- 8.2 mm
- Price
- 2332.00
Mazzini Ice Leopard
225/45 R17 94T XLCategory scores (% of best)
All discipline results (13)
Discipline positions compare the ranked tires in this test, not the whole market. These are individual measurements, not weighted overall scores.
| Test | Position in discipline | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry BrakingLower is better | 2nd / 8 | 106 ft | +3 ft |
| Subj. Dry HandlingHigher is better | 4th / 8 | 3 Points | -2.00 Points |
| Wet BrakingLower is better | 1st / 8 | 113 ft | Best in this discipline |
| Wet HandlingLower is better | 2nd / 8 | 41.4 s | +0.70 s |
| Straight AquaHigher is better | 2nd / 8 | 44.2 mph | -1.8 mph |
| Snow BrakingLower is better | 8th / 8 | 42 ft | +2 ft |
| Snow TractionLower is better | 8th / 8 | 4.45 s | +0.35 s |
| Snow HandlingLower is better | 8th / 8 | 78 s | +2.90 s |
| Ice BrakingLower is better | 7th / 8 | 58 ft | +22 ft |
| Ice TractionLower is better | 7th / 8 | 7.99 s | +3.38 s |
| Ice HandlingLower is better | 8th / 8 | 52.2 s | +4.40 s |
| NoiseLower is better | 4th / 8 | 74.8 dB | +3.30 dB |
| Fuel ConsumptionLower is better | 6th / 8 | 5.65 l/100km | +0.40 l/100km |
- Shore
- 123
- Stud Count
- 61
- 3PMSF
- Yes
- Weight
- 10.7 kgs
- Tread
- 9 mm
- Price
- 1179.00

Discussion