Covering 14 of the leading winter tires in 205/55 R16, AMS puts them through their paces with the typical thoroughness of a German magazine.
Test source Auto Motor Und Sport
2011 AMS Winter Tire Test
Overall test winnerGoodyear UltraGrip 8
We might be well into the winter tire season, but this excellent winter tire test from Auto Motor und Sport was too good to ignore.
- Tires tested
- 14
- Tested size
- 205/55 R16
At a glance
Tire shortlist
Published finishing positions, with the strengths and considerations from this test. Owner reviews cover other sizes and driving conditions.
+Very good handling, good traction and short braking distances on snow, good wet performances, good comfort.
−Stopping distance in dry conditions are not optimal
+Very good handling characteristics and short braking distances on wet, snow-good characteristics, low noise.
−Stopping distance in dry conditions are not optimal.
+Well-balanced driving characteristics under all conditions, very short wet braking, good comfort.
−Only moderate aquaplaning properties.
+Currently the best properties in the winter-competitive environment, good handling in dry conditions.
−Only moderate wet performances.
+Well-balanced driving characteristics under all conditions, wet braking distances short, good comfort, low noise.
−Snow traction is not optimal.
+Good handling characteristics, short braking distance and snow traction, good wet performances.
−Only moderate aquaplaning properties.
+Good handling characteristics and short braking distances and good traction on snow, very low rolling resistance.
−Poor aquaplaning properties.
+Good handling on dry roads, good comfort, low noise levels.
−Only average snow traction, moderate aquaplaning properties.
+Very good handling, good traction and short braking distances on snow.
−Average properties in wet and dry, high rolling resistance.
+Very good handling, good traction and short braking distances on snow.
−Average properties in wet and dry, high rolling resistance.
+Good driving comfort and low road noise, satisfactory performance on snow.
−Long dry braking distance, high rolling resistance.
−Good handling and very good braking performance on dry roads.
+Very good driving characteristics on dry roads, good comfort.
−Unsatisfactory handling on snow, just average in the wet.
+Good handling characteristics on dry roads, good comfort.
−Unsatisfactory handling on snow, average in the wet.
Select 2–8 tires to compare
The full test
The evidence behind the verdict
Covering 14 of the leading winter tires in 205/55 R16, AMS puts them through their paces with the typical thoroughness of a German magazine.


He can't be the Pilot Alpin 4 on this test because he doesn't exist in 16". That must be a Alpin 4 ;)
You are correct :) We will get this updated soon, thank you for noticing.