Tigar Winter 1 vs Kleber Krisalp HP3
In the 3 independent tests that ran both tires, the Kleber Krisalp HP3 finished ahead 3 times and the Winter 1 not once. The Krisalp HP3 was stronger in wet.
Performance profile
Their shared tests recorded too few of the same measurements to chart, so the chart shows what owners rate each tire on every question.
Where owners rate each higher
Winter 1
Not ahead in any category
Krisalp HP3
Point at or tap any spoke for both tires' figures.
Owners rate the Winter 1 73% from 12 reviews and the Krisalp HP3 84% from 36. Each spoke is one question owners answer out of 10; reviews are vetted by hand before publication.
Every measurement, side by side
Averages of the figures both tires posted in the same tests. The gap is the average of each test's own gap, so figures from different cars and years are never mixed. Wins count the tests in which each tire did better.
| Measurement | Winter 1 | Gap | Krisalp HP3 | Wins |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wet Krisalp HP3 ahead | ||||
| Wet Braking ft | 128 | 8.7% | 117 | 0-2 |
Braking distances and lap times are better when lower; speeds, wear and grip figures when higher. A test's figures are its own: sizes, cars, surfaces and temperatures differ from one to the next, which is why the averages here are only ever of tests the two tires shared.
Head to head in 3 tests, 2017 to 2025
Each row is one published test in which both tires ran on the same car, in the same size, on the same day. The line is the whole field, winner on the left.
| Test | Winter 1 | Field | Krisalp HP3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 Winter Tire Braking Test - 52 Sets! | P38 of 51 | P12 of 51 | |
| 2023 Winter Tire Test 54 Set Braking Test | P36 of 54 | P4 of 54 | |
| 2017 50 Winter Tire Shoot Out | P44 of 50 | P10 of 50 |
Winter 1 vs Krisalp HP3: your questions
Is the Tigar Winter 1 or the Kleber Krisalp HP3 the better tire?
In the 3 independent tests that ran both tires, the Kleber Krisalp HP3 finished ahead 3 times and the Winter 1 not once. On the Tire Reviews Score, which weighs every test and review we hold, the Winter 1 scores 7.2 and the Krisalp HP3 8.1 out of 10.
Which is better in the wet, the Winter 1 or the Krisalp HP3?
The Krisalp HP3 led 2 of the 2 wet measurements the shared tests recorded. On average it stopped 8.7% shorter in the wet across 2 tests.
Which is quieter and more comfortable?
Owners rate comfort 7.8/10 for the Winter 1 and 8.8/10 for the Krisalp HP3.
What do owners say?
Owners rate the Winter 1 73% from 12 reviews and the Krisalp HP3 84% from 36. 64% of Winter 1 owners would buy it again, against 71% for the Krisalp HP3.
Are they available in the same sizes?
The Winter 1 is made in 14 sizes (13 to 14 inch) and the Krisalp HP3 in 75 (14 to 20 inch). 8 sizes are available in both. On the EU label the Winter 1 is graded D for wet grip and E for rolling resistance in most sizes; the Krisalp HP3 B and D.
Which is the newer tire?
The Krisalp HP3 is the newer design: it reached the market in 2016, the Winter 1 in 2007. The Krisalp HP3 replaced the Kleber Krisalp HP2.
More comparisons with these tires
vs 
Barum Polaris 6 vs Kleber Krisalp HP3
2-1 in 4 shared tests
vs
Firestone Winterhawk 4 vs Kleber Krisalp HP3
5-10 in 15 shared tests
vs
Hankook Winter I cept RS3 vs Kleber Krisalp HP3
6-0 in 6 shared tests
vs
Hankook Winter i cept evo3 vs Kleber Krisalp HP3
5-3 in 8 shared tests
vs
BFGoodrich gForce Winter 2 vs Kleber Krisalp HP3
13-5 in 20 shared tests
vs 
Kleber Krisalp HP3 vs Michelin Pilot Alpin 5
0-11 in 11 shared tests
vs
Fulda Kristall Control HP2 vs Kleber Krisalp HP3
4-18 in 22 shared tests
vs
Goodyear UltraGrip Performance 3 vs Kleber Krisalp HP3
8-1 in 10 shared tests
Run either of these?
Your review is the part of this page no test can supply: how the tire wore, how it aged, what it was like in the rain in year three. It takes about five minutes.
Where this data comes from
Finishing positions and measurements are transcribed from each published test. A test only counts here when both tires ran in it, so every figure was recorded on the same car, size and day as the one it is compared to.
About the TR Score
The Tire Reviews Score rates each tire out of 10 from every independent test result and vetted owner review we hold, so two tires can be compared even before a test has run them together.
Who does the testing
Every test published as a Tire Reviews test is run by Jonathan Benson, who has been testing tires independently since 2007.