Adjust Result Weighting
The overall scores below are calculated using our weighting system. Since the original publication may use a different scoring methodology that wasn't shared, these results may differ from their published rankings. You can adjust the weightings below to explore how different priorities affect the results.
Test Results Data
Good
Below Average
42
BEST
Bar length in each cell shows performance versus the class leader; longer bars mean stronger performance. The class-leading value in each column appears in bold. The Total Score reflects the weighted sum of all categories.
| # | Tire | Total Score | Dry | Wet | Comfort | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Braking M | Handling s | Subj. Dry Handling Points | % | Braking M | Handling s | Subj. Wet Handling Points | Straight Aqua Km/H | % | Subj. Comfort Points | % | |||
| 1 | Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 | 98.6% | 35.2 | 92.98 | 7 | 94.2% | 34.5 | 90.36 | 9 | 63.51 | 99.4% | 9 | 100% |
| 2 ▼1 | Goodyear Eagle F1 SuperSport | 97.2% | 34.3 | 91.53 | 8 | 97.1% | 35.6 | 88.95 | 8 | 59.76 | 96.7% | 7.5 | 83.3% |
| 3 ▼2 | Goodyear Eagle F1 SuperSport R | 88.2% | 33 | 91.11 | 9 | 100% | 43.2 | 100.95 | 5 | 49.49 | 79.9% | 6.5 | 72.2% |
Scroll for more
Dry
94%
Wet
99%
Comfort
100%
View detailed scores
Dry
Dry Braking
35.2 M
Dry Handling
92.98 s
Subj. Dry Handling
7 Points
Wet
Wet Braking
34.5 M
Wet Handling
90.36 s
Subj. Wet Handling
9 Points
Straight Aqua
63.51 Km/H
Comfort
Subj. Comfort
9 Points
Dry
97%
Wet
97%
Comfort
83%
View detailed scores
Dry
Dry Braking
34.3 M
Dry Handling
91.53 s
Subj. Dry Handling
8 Points
Wet
Wet Braking
35.6 M
Wet Handling
88.95 s
Subj. Wet Handling
8 Points
Straight Aqua
59.76 Km/H
Comfort
Subj. Comfort
7.5 Points
Dry
100%
Wet
80%
Comfort
72%
View detailed scores
Dry
Dry Braking
33 M
Dry Handling
91.11 s
Subj. Dry Handling
9 Points
Wet
Wet Braking
43.2 M
Wet Handling
100.95 s
Subj. Wet Handling
5 Points
Straight Aqua
49.49 Km/H
Comfort
Subj. Comfort
6.5 Points
Not every driver has the same priorities. Adjust the category weightings above to re-rank the tires based on what matters most to your driving style.
Each cell shows a bar comparing the tire to the class leader for that test — a longer bar means stronger performance. Bar colour matches the test category.
The original test ranking is shown in the # column. Arrows indicate how each tire moves when your custom weighting is applied.
Hello,
I have a 2012 Lexus GS450H and looking for a new set of tires. First of all i want to say thank you for your amazing reviews as it s very difficult to find some good advice. I live in England and i use the car mostly to travel and i like to push it sometimes as it has 340hp and can be pretty fun. I drive about 2000 miles a month on average, what tire would you recommend me? 235/ 45 R18 98Y
Many thanks in advance,
Stephan.
The PS4S or Asymmetric 5 would be a good option depending on local pricing and how much you rate comfort.
Thank you! I had GY Asymmetric 3 on my old Z4 3.0i and i was very happy but after doing more research looks like Michelin’s is the better choice despite the higher price. I check at Costco and the guys they only did PS4S for 19” or bigger so i will have to go with the PS4. They have really good offers every 3 weeks. The comfort would be on the first place. Talking about comfort, what (good) options are out there for tires with foam inside to reduce the noise/ improve comfort?
Many thanks
Great review, thank you. I need new rubber for my Lexus GSF - large RWD V8. Daily driver + spirited mountain driving sometimes but no track time. Australian roads are no better than the UK, if not worse. Factory tire was Michelin Pilot SS. Can’t decide bw PS4S, Asymm 5 & GY SuperSport. Your expert opinion would be greatly appreciated. Cheers.
Sorry I missed the alert for this. How important is comfort? I think the default answer would be the PS4S
Hey Jonathan...
I bought a Megane RS Trophy last year and after the first year of having fun the original Bridgestone S001 are shredded... So I need to find a new tire for this beasty hot hatch. (245/35 R19)
My opinion is the Bridgestoen Potenza is not the best option for a front drive with
limited-slip differential... it feels like the power is not on the road and the steering doesnt feel nice and pointy. Also the feeling for the road is not the best.
At the moment your videos on YT pushed me from Continental Sport Contact 6 and Michelin Pilot Sport 4S to the GY SuperSport and the Asymmetric 5...but I also have the Vredestein Ultrac Vorti in mind, but I cant find a comparison. Wich one would you recommend for a hot hatch... Thx!
F1 SuperSport or SportContact 6 for steering precision :)
Thx for the fast response...
The lack of comfort and the increased wear and tear is therefore worth the handling and the dry grip you would say...
You said you wanted handling so I would assume so!
Noticed you mentioned below you would pick SS on a M240i.
Would you go with the Asym 5 or the SS for a Lexus IS200 turbo, which doesn't quite have the same levels of power and isn't something you would chuck into corners as much?
Sorry, forgot to add the size I'm looking at are 235/35/19.
It depends what you're preference is, comfort or handling as that's the small differences between the two tires :)
Thanks, have decided to go with the Asym 5 for just a little more comfort as I live in Singapore and I do mostly city driving plus the car won't be used on the track at all.
Will comment again with feedback after I've had the tires on for a couple of months (including whether I wish I had gone for the SS instead).
Can't decide on the Goodyear Supersport, Asym 5 or Michelin PS4 for my BMW M240i. Running wider 18 inch BBS CH-R rims so could go to 255 rear (stock is 245) but the Goodyear Supersports are not available yet in this size. Which would you choose ?
SuperSport :) Check out the youtube channel this afternoon for SuperSport vs PS4S on an M2.
All four Tires are due an upgrade from Asymetric 3 at the rear and MPSS up front on my 2016 M135i .
Looking for increased grip in the wet and overall better traction off the line, living in England as you know it rains forever. 50/50 split between commuter miles and spirited drives.
The Asymmetric 5 seems to be a great in the wet. However the Supersport seems to be the overall better performer. Stuck!
Tricky. The SuperSport might be marginally better in the wet, but the Asym 5 might be a slightly better tire for those commuter miles.
As it's me, I'd always go for more UHP bias on an M135i, so go for the SuperSport. IT'll also feel more MPSS like on the front axle.
Brilliant! I appreciate the insight. I would go for the mps4 however its only available in 19' and above. The Supersports seem to be its direct competitor. Costco have a sale on Goodyear tires tomorrow so will be grabbing myself a new set!! Excited! ?
Sweet, leave a review when you've done some miles :)
I am very intersted to get the Asysmmetric 5 or the supersport for my Nissan 200SX S14. But they are not available in the same sizes.
I would like to drive 18 inch 225/40 in the front and 18 inch 245/35 in the back for road use. For drifting I switch back to my actual 17 inch 225 all around. The Suspension is setup relativly neutral for drifting with the 225s and I would like to get it more understeery for road use by only changing the wheels.
The Asymmetric 5 is available in 225/40 R18 and 245/35 R18 but the supersport is only available in as 225/40 r18. What would you suggest?
If you're making the switch for stability, you'd be smart to match the same tires all round as the Asym 5 and SS will have slightly different roll characteristics.
Yes for sure. mix match of the the Tire type would be silly. But I am unsure to go with 225 SS all around or with Asm 5 225 front and 245 rear.
On that sort of car I'd run 225 all round, 245 doesn't buy you MUCH more grip (check out the tire width video we've done on this) and the SuperSport is a sportier feeling tire
really good Video! Thnx for your suggestion. Now I am sure to go with the Supersport
Great video! After having watched this and other two reviews you made (Michelin PS4/ PS4S/ PSS and UHP summer tire test), I have narrowed down to 2 options for my 2016 Focus RS (for 80% road and 20% track usage): Either Michelin's PS4S or Goodyear's F1 SuperSport.
A bit of a tough choice - which one would you chose (disregarding the price difference, as in my country there is none) :)
Thanks in advance!
Good question. Both tires are excellent, both are test winning, both are ok on track. It might come down to which brand you prefer if the price is the same!
Highly appreciate your swift reply! I will go for the ones with the most recent DOT I'll find in stock.
Either way, I will post a review in a few months, after the first track day (April) :)
Cheers!
I look forward to the review :)
So, for a dedicated track day Tire (on which the car will also be driven to the track) would you recommend the Supersport or the Supersport R?
Also, how would you rate either of these against the Advan AD08Rs?
R for sure.
I've not tested the Yoko.
Sooo I dont know what wheel to fit, Goodyear F1 Supersport, or Michelin PS2 (they about same price). I am driving a FWD 180HP Seat Toledo 20VT and I exclusively drive in the streets, with high temperatures (Spain). I value confort and low noise. Maybe should I fit different brands in front and rear? Thanks for your videos and tests :)
Easy, SuperSport. The PS2 is a very old tire.
Thanks. well I dont think old means worse, for instance PS2 is actually a lot better than PS3. But yeah I just fell in love with the F1 Supersport. Fortunately I didn't buy the Assymetric 5 last week haha (those are awesome tires too anyway).
No surprises, eh? ;)
I was very surprised here the Supersport was that much faster in the wet, when I expected it to be equal at best, or a bit worse to the A5. E.g. the PS4 and PS4S were equal in the tirereviews test last year.
Amazing blend of wet and dry performance on the Supersport, very happy with mine and these tests confirm it's not me imagining things :)
Thanks for the test and vid!
Now confused, in the vid the SS was significantly faster than the A5 in the wet, but in the stats above they are the same? And times are different? @Tirereviews
I tired in 89 instead of 88 for the SuperSports wet lap, thanks for noticing.
How should I go about interpreting the reviews for AWD supercars? Front tires vs rear, as to balance? Wet and dry.
I'm not sure I understand the question, sorry
The tests were done on a 2 wheel drive car with moderate HP. How would the results differ on an 800wHp AWD supercar, since you can't really drift? Even with traction control turned off.
In theory the overall results would remain the same, but the more track focused tires dry advantage might be slightly extended.