Menu

Michelin CrossClimate 2 vs Continental AllSeasonContact 2 vs BFGoodrich Advantage All-Season vs Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3

4 tires 3 shared tests All Season 2024-2025 2 publications

4 tires ranked on the 3 independent tests that drove all of them together. Every measurement is scored against the best of the group, then weighted by discipline; move the weighting and the leaderboard re-ranks.

The quick answer

On the Balanced weighting the Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 leads with 97.6%, 0.1 points ahead of the Michelin CrossClimate 2.

  1. 1 Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 97.6%leads 1-0-2 9.6/10 75 reviews
  2. 2 Michelin CrossClimate 2 97.5%0.1 pts behind 0-0-3 9.5/10 179 reviews
  3. 3 Continental AllSeasonContact 2 97.1%0.5 pts behind 2-0-1 9.5/10 74 reviews
  4. 4 BFGoodrich Advantage All-Season 96.2%1.4 pts behind 0-0-3 9.5/10 1 review

Scores are relative: in every measurement the best tire of the group scores 100% and the rest are scaled to it, so a tire can rank first here and still trail a tire that never shared a test with it. Data updated November 2026.

Leaderboard

Each discipline score is the weighted mean of its measurements across the 3 shared tests, and the total is the weighted mean of the disciplines. Pick a preset or set the sliders yourself, then update: the table below re-ranks without leaving the page.

Adjust Category Weighting

Adjust the importance of each performance category to see how different priorities affect the overall ranking across all shared tests.

Dry 25%
Wet 34%
Snow 25%
Ice 5%
Comfort 5%
Value 5%
Environment 1%
Dry 25% · Wet 34% · Snow 25% · Ice 5% · Comfort 5% · Value 5% · Environment 1%
Fine-tune sub-categories
Dry
Wet
Snow
Ice
Comfort
Value
Environment
RankTireScoreDryWetSnowIceComfortValueEnvironment
1Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF397.6%100%99.3%95.4%96.1%99.4%88.5%80.6%
2Michelin CrossClimate 297.5%98%94.8%99%100%99.9%99.9%100%
3Continental AllSeasonContact 297.1%95.3%99%97.8%94.9%100%93.9%72.9%
4BFGoodrich Advantage All-Season96.2%97.8%92.8%99.4%96.7%99.9%93.7%87.4%

Discipline columns show the score on the current weighting; 100% means the tire was best of the group in every measurement of that discipline.

Performance overview

One axis per measurement, with the best tire of the group at the rim. The larger the shape, the fewer weak spots.

Every measurement

Averaged across the shared tests, in the unit each test recorded. The direction under each title says which way is better.

Dry Braking [ft] (lower is better)

Dry Handling [mph] (higher is better)

Wet Braking [ft] (lower is better)

Wet Braking - Concrete [ft] (lower is better)

Wet Handling [mph] (higher is better)

Wet Circle [s] (lower is better)

Straight Aqua [mph] (higher is better)

Curved Aquaplaning [ft/s²] (higher is better)

Snow Braking [ft] (lower is better)

Snow Traction [lbf] (higher is better)

Snow Handling [mph] (higher is better)

Snow Slalom [ft/s²] (higher is better)

Ice Braking [ft] (lower is better)

Noise [dB] (lower is better)

Wear [miles] (higher is better)

Value [Price/1000] (lower is better)

Rolling Resistance [kg / t] (lower is better)

Fuel Consumption [l/100km] (lower is better)

Abrasion [mg/km/t] (lower is better)

Abrasion [g] (lower is better)

Full data table

The averaged figure behind every bar above, grouped by discipline. The best figure in each row is marked.

MetricMichelin CrossClimate 2Continental AllSeasonContact 2BFGoodrich Advantage All-SeasonPirelli Cinturato All Season SF3
Dry
Dry Braking ftlower is better125132128122
Dry Handling mphhigher is better58.758.459.659.5
Wet
Wet Braking ftlower is better160151167153
Wet Braking - Concrete ftlower is better133126138127
Wet Handling mphhigher is better44.746.843.946.7
Wet Circle slower is better11.8911.412.111.53
Straight Aqua mphhigher is better46.745.347.249
Curved Aquaplaning ft/s²higher is better99.19.410
Snow
Snow Braking ftlower is better54555458
Snow Traction lbfhigher is better332327337329
Snow Handling mphhigher is better34.234.433.833.1
Snow Slalom ft/s²higher is better1413.614.313.5
Ice
Ice Braking ftlower is better49515051
Comfort
Noise dBlower is better72.2572.1572.272.55
Value
Wear mileshigher is better34231303012834427878
Value Price/1000lower is better6.877.697.067.96
Rolling Resistance kg / tlower is better7.47.537.718.24
Fuel Consumption l/100kmlower is better5.195.265.175.38
Environment
Abrasion mg/km/tlower is better53676060
Abrasion glower is better527791609723

Test-by-test record

Across the 3 shared tests, the tire that finished highest takes the win; a tie at the top is a draw. The finishing positions are against the whole field of each test, not just these tires.

# Tire Wins Draws Losses Avg. position Best
1 Continental AllSeasonContact 2 2 0 1 2.3 P2
2 Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 1 0 2 3.3 P2
3 Michelin CrossClimate 2 0 0 3 4 P3
4 BFGoodrich Advantage All-Season 0 0 3 8.7 P7

The 3 shared tests

Test Cinturato All Season SF3 CrossClimate 2 AllSeasonContact 2 Advantage All-Season
2025 ADAC All Season Tire Test 2025 · 225/45 R17 · ADAC · field of 16 P3 P5 P2 P7
2024 AutoBild All Season Tire Test 2024 · 225/50 R17 · Auto Bild · field of 17 P5 P3 P2 P10
2024 All Season Tire Market Overview 2024 · 225/50 R17 · Auto Bild · field of 37 P2 P4 P3 P9

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is the best tire overall?

Across 3 shared independent tests, the Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 ranks highest overall with a score of 97.6%, ahead of the Michelin CrossClimate 2 (97.5%).

Which tire has the best wet braking?

The Continental AllSeasonContact 2 has the best wet braking across 3 shared tests, averaging 151ft.

Which tire has the best dry braking?

The Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 has the best dry braking across 3 shared tests, averaging 122ft.

Which tire has the best wear?

The Michelin CrossClimate 2 has the best wear across 3 shared tests, averaging 34231miles.

Which tire has the best rolling resistance?

The Michelin CrossClimate 2 has the best rolling resistance across 3 shared tests, averaging 7.4kg / t.

Which tire has the best snow braking?

The Michelin CrossClimate 2 has the best snow braking across 3 shared tests, averaging 54ft.

Which tire do owners rate highest?

The BFGoodrich Advantage All-Season has the highest owner rating at 86% from 1 review.

Build your own group

Any two to eight tires that have been in the same independent test can be ranked the same way.

Compare three or more tires All comparisons

Run one of these?

Your review adds what no test can: how the tire wore, how it aged, what it was like in the rain in year three. It takes about five minutes.

Review the Cinturato All Season SF3 Review the CrossClimate 2 Review the AllSeasonContact 2

Where this data comes from

Measurements and finishing positions are transcribed from each published test. A test only counts here when every tire in the group ran in it, so each figure was recorded on the same car, size and day as the ones beside it.

About the scoring

In each measurement the best average of the group scores 100% and the others are scaled to it. Discipline scores weight those measurements, the total weights the disciplines, and the default weighting follows the season of the tires.

Who does the testing

Every test published as a Tyre Reviews test is run by Jonathan Benson, who has been testing tires independently since 2007.

Rate your tires

My tires

Saved in this browser on this site. No account needed. Clearing browser data removes your choices.

Vehicle and size

Check the size, load and speed ratings on your vehicle. Saving a size does not confirm fitment.

Saved tires

Save tires from a tire page, test or comparison to keep them here.

Select 2–8 saved tires. Ranked comparisons require at least two shared tests.

Where to buy

Affiliate links: if you buy, we may earn a commission. It never changes our tests, scores or recommendations. How we stay independent