The Toyo A23 is a Touring All Season tire designed to be fitted to Passenger Cars.
The quick answer
Owners say61%from 10 owner reviews44% would buy againRead the reviews
Tests saySorry, we don't currently have any test data for the Toyo A23
Built from every independent test result and vetted owner review we hold for this tire - the evidence is all further down the page. Data updated June 2025.
Owners rate the Toyo A23 6.6 out of 10 for comfort and noise across 10 reviews.
How well do the Toyo A23 wear, according to owners?
Owners rate the Toyo A23 6.4 out of 10 for wear across 10 reviews. 6 of those reviews come from owners past 10,000 miles, and the typical review covers 18,000 miles.
Would owners buy the Toyo A23 again?
44% of owners say they would buy the Toyo A23 again, based on the 9 owner reviews that answered the question. 22% of them gave it the highest possible answer.
What do owners say about the Toyo A23's tread life?
Of the 10 owner reviews analyzed for the Toyo A23, 8 mention tread life: 6 praise it (long-lasting) and 2 criticise it (wears quickly). One owner wrote: "We’ve clocked around 30,000 miles on some units with even wear". Read those reviews
Across 10 owner ratings the Toyo A23 averages 61%. Owners rate Dry Grip highest at 7.8 out of 10 and Ice Grip lowest at 3.7. 6 of those reviews come from owners past 10,000 miles. 33% of owners score it 70% or better.
Owner ratings averaged from 10 ratings
Owner score61%
Dry Grip78%
Road Feedback77%
Comfort66%
Wear64%
Handling63%
Snow Grip60%
Wet Grip59%
Ice Grip37%
Featured reviews
Most helpful 69%
“Reliable Tire for Mixed Conditions – Solid Performer for Fleet Use We've been using the Toyo A23 across a small fleet operating in both urban and rural environments. One of the standout features is its quiet and...”
“They are a cheap OEM tire, I think they're probably fine off the lot, but I bought this car used from the dealership and have only experienced them after 25,000 miles of ware. I will say they are lasting me slightly...”
“The ride quality is ok, apart from the noise. Lots of road noise. But I cannot believe how quickly these wear. We live in Alaska so for at least 6 months a year we run on winter tires. The car has just turned 50,000...”
Reliable Tire for Mixed Conditions – Solid Performer for Fleet Use
We've been using the Toyo A23 across a small fleet operating in both urban and rural environments. One of the standout features is its quiet and comfortable ride even at higher motorway speeds. Dry grip is solid and cornering stability is acceptable for a mid-range compound. Wet performance is decent, though not quite at premium-tier levels — but for its price, it delivers great value.https://tirevortex.com/mobile-coach-tire-services/
What makes it particularly suitable for long-term use is the tread longevity. We’ve clocked around 30,000 miles on some units with even wear, which is excellent for the weight they carry.
For anyone managing a transport business, I’d strongly recommend looking into Fleet Tire Maintenance for Coaches to maximise tire lifespan and ensure road safety — especially when combining it with reliable mid-range options like the Toyo A23.
Would I buy again? Definitely — especially for non-performance fleets and general use cases.
The dealership sold me these tires since the first batch wore out. I have 55,000 miles on my car and have had to replace these twice now and they arent cheap. Got only 25,000 miles out of this last time. Too bad the dealership wont stand behind these awful tires. Spend a little more and get some good quality. Had I known I would have never bought these. Buyer be aware!!!
Check out how the BEST all seasons tires perform against premium summer and winter tires!
37%
Member
Mazda
225/45 R17
30,000 miles
Mostly Town
Average
They are a cheap OEM tire, I think they're probably fine off the lot, but I bought this car used from the dealership and have only experienced them after 25,000 miles of ware. I will say they are lasting me slightly over the recommended 30k, so that is a plus. For the cost of these tires, the performance does not justify the lack of longevity.
Which tires do you drive?
Researching the Toyo A23? Rate the tires you actually drive - and help the next buyer choose.
Good wear, fine on the Highway and dry conditions. Pretty ordinary in the wet though.
95%
Member
Mitsubishi
265/60 R18
18,000 miles
Mostly Country Roads
Easy Going
Brilliant tires. No wear showing after 18,000 miles. I do not thrash it around. It is a big 4x4 Shogun Sport 2021 , and I drive accordingly on roads. Tires very good off road. Never got stuck yet, and been in some very muddy tracks
The ride quality is ok, apart from the noise. Lots of road noise. But I cannot believe how quickly these wear. We live in Alaska so for at least 6 months a year we run on winter tires. The car has just turned 50,000 miles in total, but these tire were only on the car half the time and yet they now need replacing. So at most I'd guess we got 30000 miles from these Toyo tires. That's terrible. Now upgraded to Michelins for not much more money.
I have just taken delivery of a new shogun sport4 fitted with TOYO A23 Open Country tires and I’ve just experienced the most terrifying 350 mile trip in mostly wet conditions! These tires are absolutely treacherous. On just about every wet round about the vehicle slipped. I honestly had to treat each one as if there was sheet ice on it. I’m definitely getting them changed and not at my expense that’s for sure!
