Menu
Kelly Edge AS View Gallery (1)

Kelly Edge AS

Kelly Tires Touring All Season

The Kelly Edge AS is a Touring All Season tire designed to be fitted to Passenger Cars.

6.4
Tire Reviews Score Based on User Reviews
Limited Confidence View Breakdown
Dry Grip
73%
Wet Grip
61%
Road Feedback
62%
Handling
59%
Wear
42%
Comfort
58%
Buy again
38%
Snow Grip
64%
Ice Grip
68%
9 Reviews
58% Average
136,600 miles driven
Kelly Edge AS

Kelly Edge AS

All Season Economy
BETA
6.4 / 10
Based on User Reviews · Limited Confidence · Updated 23 Feb 2026

The Tire Reviews Score is the most comprehensive tire scoring system available. It aggregates professional test data from multiple independent publications, user reviews, and consistency analysis using Bayesian statistical methods, weighted normalisation, and recency-adjusted scoring to produce a single, reliable performance rating.

Learn more about our methodology
Score Components
Professional Tests
Weight: 80%
Tests: 0
Publications: 0
User Reviews
Weight: 15%
Reviews: 9
Avg Rating: 58.2%
Min Required: 5
Consistency
Weight: 5%
Score Std Dev: 2.56
History Points: 10
Methodology & Configuration
Scoring Process
  1. Collect Test Data: Gather results from professional tire tests across multiple publications. Minimum 1 test(s) required.
  2. Normalize Positions: Convert test positions to percentile scores using exponential weighting (factor: 1.2).
  3. Apply Recency Weighting: More recent tests are weighted higher with a decay rate of 0.95.
  4. Incorporate User Reviews: Factor in user review data (minimum 5 reviews). Weight: 15%.
  5. Bayesian Smoothing: Apply Bayesian prior (score: 7, weight: 1.5) to prevent extreme scores with limited data.
  6. Calculate Final Score: Combine all components using normalization factor of 1.1. Max score with limited data: 9.5.
Component Weights
Test Data
80%
User Reviews
15%
Consistency
5%
All Configuration Parameters
ParameterValueDescription
safety_weight 0.7 Weight multiplier for safety-related metrics
performance_weight 0.55 Weight multiplier for performance metrics
comfort_weight 0.4 Weight multiplier for comfort metrics
value_weight 0.45 Weight multiplier for value-for-money metrics
user_reviews_weight 0.15 How much user reviews contribute to the final score
test_data_weight 0.8 How much professional test data contributes to the final score
consistency_weight 0.05 How much score consistency contributes to the final score
recency_decay_rate 0.95 Rate at which older test results lose influence (higher = slower decay)
min_test_count 1 Minimum number of professional tests required
min_review_count 5 Minimum number of user reviews required
score_version 1.9 Current version of the scoring algorithm
score_normalization_factor 1.1 Factor used to normalize raw scores to the 0-10 scale
confidence_factor_weight 0.2 How much data confidence affects the final score
position_penalty_weight 0.2 Penalty applied for poor test positions
gap_penalty_threshold 12 Score gap (%) that triggers additional penalties
min_metrics_count 2 Minimum number of test metrics needed per test
limited_data_threshold 2 Number of tests below which data is considered limited
single_test_penalty 0.75 Score multiplier when only one test is available
critical_metric_penalty 0.7 Penalty for poor performance on critical safety metrics
critical_metric_threshold 70 Score below which a critical metric penalty applies
position_exponential_factor 1.2 Exponent used to amplify position-based scoring
position_exponential_threshold 0.9 Position percentile below which exponential scoring applies
gap_multiplier_critical 3 Multiplier for critical gap penalties
max_category_weight 2 Maximum weight any single category can have
max_score_limited_data 9.5 Score cap when data is limited
bayesian_prior_weight 1.5 Weight of the Bayesian prior in smoothing
bayesian_prior_score 7 Prior score used for Bayesian smoothing
evidence_test_multiplier 1.9 Multiplier for test evidence in confidence calculation
evidence_metric_divisor 3 Divisor for metric count in evidence calculation
evidence_review_divisor 10 Divisor for review count in evidence calculation
combined_penalty_floor 0.2
All Tests

Sorry, we don't currently have any magazine tire tests for the Kelly Edge AS

Questions and Answers for the Kelly Edge AS

Ask a question
Sorry, we don't currently have any questions and answers for the Kelly Edge AS. Why not submit a question to our tire experts using the form below!
Ask a question

We will never publish or share your email address

captcha

To verify you are human please type the word you see in the box below.

Top 3 Kelly Edge AS Reviews

Given 43% while driving a Toyota Venza USA (225/45 R19) on mostly motorways for 0 average miles
I drove these with my Venza and only got like 7000 miles on them. Only realized they were worn after they started skidding in light rain
Helpful 671
September 26, 2024
Given 72% while driving a Lincoln (245/60 R18) on a combination of roads for 50,000 average miles
This tire relies on the vehicle it is mounted on which makes reviewing it difficult however we have an all wheel drive Lincoln and are considering a third set, after tires get use over 50% they start getting noisy and we use them in the northern half of lower Michigan. This Lincoln is AWD.
Helpful 849
August 17, 2023
Given 59% while driving a Honda (225/65 R17) on mostly town for 55,000 average miles
I bought these tires for my 2011 Honda RV in Dec 2020. My mileage. was at 116735 . I am currently at 141534 miles as of July 2023 so I don't do an excessive amount of driving.My warranty is 55000. I cant get anyone from the Mr Tire Auto Service where I bought them from to even return my calls. Not surprised as the service was horrible there
Helpful 798
August 8, 2023

How would you rate the Kelly Edge AS?

Click a star to start your review

193 reviews submitted this month Earn your Contributor badge No account needed

Latest Kelly Edge AS Reviews

Given 43% while driving a Toyota Sienna (225/45 R17) on mostly town for 7,000 easy going miles
Only got 7,000 miles out of the tires.
Warranty Was 55,000 miles and company will not stand by tires. Will not ever buy any tire from Kelly again.
Helpful 780
July 11, 2023
Given 67% while driving a Subaru 2015+ STI (255/35 R18) on a combination of roads for 2,000 spirited miles
Honestly, for grip never. Daily and regular car if you drive like a grandma kind of beats. Giving these tires some power already feels like you’re going to slip out.
Helpful 795
July 7, 2023
Check out how the BEST all seasons tires perform against premium summer and winter tires!
Given 84% while driving a Kia Motors Forte (225/45 R17) on mostly town for 2,000 average miles
Quality entry level performance tire. Nice road feel and very quiet. Not a great performer on a wet track but enough grip for a bit of confidence. Very good tire for the $$$.
Helpful 760
September 27, 2022
Given 28% while driving a Subaru Forester 2.5i (/55 R18) on mostly town for 500 spirited miles
came on a subaru forester bought at carmax. the put very cheap new tires on every car sold, so they look nice and new. but my trade in had michelin defenders on it, and it rode much quieter, handled better, braked better. and my trade in was a cheap kia soul. can't wait to get michelin CrossClimate 2 on this forester, or at least general Altimax, either would be a huge upgrade and i would feel much safer driving them especially in rain and snow...
Helpful 881
April 1, 2022
Given 76% while driving a Toyota scion XB (/55 R16) on a combination of roads for 20,000 easy going miles
I am comparing them to Douglas tires from Walmart which were on the my 2011 scion xB when I bought it used. These Kelley tires have a noticeably stronger sidewalls than the Douglas tires and handle better.
Helpful 973
September 19, 2021
Given 33% while driving a Chevrolet Cavalier (/45 R17) on mostly country roads for 100 easy going miles
Extremely rough ride. Felt every crack in the road. Had to return.
Helpful 858
August 24, 2021
Rate the Kelly Edge AS