Menu

Goodyear Excellence Owner Reviews

Review this tire

What owners say summarised from 113 reviews

Owners most consistently praise the Goodyear Excellence for dry grip, with comfort and relatively quiet running also receiving more praise than criticism. Wet grip is generally well regarded but less consistent, with roughly one in eight reviews reporting shortcomings. Longer-term accounts range from good life to early replacement, and around one in five reviews criticise wear. Noise complaints appear in about one in nine reviews despite the broader positive balance. Repeat reviewers have mixed experiences rather than a shared trend, so there is no consistent ageing pattern to describe.

What owners mention most counted across 113 reviews

Tap one to read only the reviews that mention it.

Owner ratings averaged from 127 ratings

  • Owner score 71%
  • Dry Grip 79%
  • Comfort 73%
  • Wear 72%
  • Road Feedback 72%
  • Handling 71%
  • Wet Grip 70%

Goodyear Excellence Reviews - Page 3

Score spread across 111 written reviews
80%
Member
  • BMW 520d
  • 225/55 R17 V
  • 20,000 miles
  • A Combination of Roads
  • Spirited
I just got 33,000 kms from these GY excellence 225/55/17 97 V runflats on my BMW520 F11 touring.
The rim protection is unreal - my rims are perfect.
I drive to West of Ireland regularly on windy, wet, hail, sun on tortuous roads. I drove through snow/slush at 29,000kms, not a bother at reasonable speeds 80-100km/h up to a half inch of slush in straight, 60-80km/h in bends.
At 32,000kms I started to notice twitching on motorway heavy rain (not a full downpour). I am down to 2mm in center of rear wheels. Front are down to 4mm, but because tracking is off I have uneven wear and have to replace front aswell, otherwise I would get several thousand more kms out of the front.
It still grips fine in 'wet' and does not aquaplane. I have only managed to 'plane twice with the car.
I drive faster than most other road users. The handling is still good.

My only complaint is noise.

This is my first year with a BMW, so I only have limited comparison. I have got +/- the same mileage out of these as I used to get on my Volvo T5 that ran GY eagle F1s 205/50/16. I used to swap front to back on the T5.

I will switch to non RFTs and will review them in a year.

...I am very technical...This is objective.
This owner's scores
  • Dry Grip 8
  • Wet Grip 8
  • Road Feedback 8
  • Handling 9
  • Wear 9
  • Comfort 6
  • Buy again 8
Helpful 544
74%
Member
These were put on by mistake by the tire fitter...I wanted goodyear efficient grip performance but got these excellence...

At first annoyed..but..i got over it. These are comfy, good in wet and dry conditions. My fronts have so far lasted 31k miles, mixed driving.
I can now feel that they need replacing (3mm left) as the wet and dry grip is noticeably worse. And will this time try my original choice of the effecientgrip performance.

By no means a sporty tire, but they last longer. I've had falkens, pirellis, hankooks but currently value more miles than high speed corner grip.
This owner's scores
  • Dry Grip 8
  • Wet Grip 8
  • Road Feedback 7
  • Handling 6
  • Wear 8
  • Comfort 8
  • Buy again 7
Helpful 557
67%
Member
It is a good tire but a little bit noisy. I experienced a really bad situation at a wet highway some months ago. I was not so fast and at a (mild)curve I suddenly lost the control of my car.
This owner's scores
  • Dry Grip 8
  • Wet Grip 5
  • Road Feedback 6
  • Handling 8
  • Wear 9
  • Comfort 6
  • Buy again 5
Helpful 496

Which tires do you drive?

Researching the Goodyear Excellence? Rate the tires you actually drive - and help the next buyer choose.

Own the Goodyear Excellence?
100%
Member
These have lasted 23k mainly town driving and have been excellent, very comfortable, smooth, quiet tires. Dry and wet grip excellent and they were fitted for £55 each 2 years ago.
This owner's scores
  • Dry Grip 10
  • Wet Grip 10
  • Road Feedback 10
  • Handling 10
  • Wear 10
  • Comfort 10
  • Buy again 10
Helpful 494
44%
Member
Tires kept the car stable but noise level was far to high for a premium tire. Constant rumble at slow speeds progressively louder at 70+ Previous tire fitted was Michelin same size but 95h smooth as silk
This owner's scores
  • Dry Grip 7
  • Wet Grip 6
  • Road Feedback 7
  • Handling 4
  • Wear 4
  • Comfort 2
  • Buy again 1
Helpful 534
86%
Member
  • Citroën C3
  • 185/60 R15 H
  • 28,000 miles
  • A Combination of Roads
  • Spirited
Used on my Citroen C3 1.6. Really honest tire, with good traction and handling on dry or wet conditions. However its noise level is just regular and the sidewall is a bit stiff, making it unfconfortable on poor tarmac conditions.

Good performance on cornering.
This owner's scores
  • Dry Grip 8
  • Wet Grip 9
  • Road Feedback 8
  • Handling 9
  • Wear 9
  • Comfort 7
  • Buy again 10
Helpful 504
96%
Member
just wish if the wear is as perfect as the mechline
This owner's scores
  • Dry Grip 10
  • Wet Grip 8
  • Road Feedback 10
  • Handling 10
  • Wear 9
  • Comfort 10
  • Buy again 10
Helpful 570
84%
Member
When I find a good tire, I will buy it again. I had three or four sets of these on my Mondeo over the course of 100,000 miles.
As the name says, excellent!
This owner's scores
  • Dry Grip 9
  • Wet Grip 9
  • Road Feedback 8
  • Handling 9
  • Wear 7
  • Comfort 7
  • Buy again 10
Helpful 486
49%
Member
  • Ford Galaxy
  • 215/60 R16 H
  • 25,000 miles
  • A Combination of Roads
  • Easy Going
Reasonable in dry as long as it's warm. Terrible in the wet even on a warm day. Don't like it at all in the cold, though they did still get traction in the snow.
This owner's scores
  • Dry Grip 4
  • Wet Grip 2
  • Road Feedback 6
  • Handling 5
  • Wear 7
  • Comfort 9
  • Buy again 1
Helpful 505
90%
Member
Just changed the original rear tires having done 82900 miles.Amazing.Still tread of mostly 3mm but showing nearer 2mm on 1 measure.Could have probably done another 10000 miles before illegal.Mostly do long journeys but have never had such good mileage from rear tires before.Excellent tires but must also be due to the configuration of the Tiguan.Apart from hard wearing, they are also quieter that most other premium tires I have tried.Needless to say I have put two new Goodyear Excellence on my car and would recommend them strongly.
This owner's scores
  • Dry Grip 8
  • Wet Grip 9
  • Road Feedback 9
  • Handling 8
  • Wear 10
  • Comfort 9
  • Buy again 10
Helpful 516
64%
Member
I had them for 35.000 km. Tires are very good in dry and wet conditions. Wear and progressivness are nor quite good.

Afer all, those tires aren't anything more than average.
This owner's scores
  • Dry Grip 9
  • Wet Grip 8
  • Road Feedback 8
  • Handling 5
  • Wear 5
  • Comfort 5
  • Buy again 5
Helpful 512
84%
Member
Very good economy, very quiet, good feeling, good grip if not forced
This owner's scores
  • Dry Grip 9
  • Wet Grip 8
  • Road Feedback 9
  • Handling 6
  • Wear 8
  • Comfort 10
  • Buy again 9
Helpful 491
Find your next tire
All tire tests
Rate your tires

My tires

Saved in this browser on this site. No account needed. Clearing browser data removes your choices.

Vehicle and size

Check the size, load and speed ratings on your vehicle. Saving a size does not confirm fitment.

Saved tires

Save tires from a tire page, test or comparison to keep them here.

Select 2–8 saved tires. Ranked comparisons require at least two shared tests.