Owners most consistently praise the Goodyear Excellence for dry grip, with comfort and relatively quiet running also receiving more praise than criticism. Wet grip is generally well regarded but less consistent, with roughly one in eight reviews reporting shortcomings. Longer-term accounts range from good life to early replacement, and around one in five reviews criticise wear. Noise complaints appear in about one in nine reviews despite the broader positive balance. Repeat reviewers have mixed experiences rather than a shared trend, so there is no consistent ageing pattern to describe.
What owners mention most counted across 113 reviews
Fitted these after the originals wore out and was initially pleased with the grip. Much better than the P6000s that were factory fitted and reasonable feedback and confidence.
Economy is definitely down though and I'm getting 55mpg rather than 60mpg. Comfort and noise ok and better than the P6000's. Wear is moderate - just about gone on the front at 12K.
The down side: they get MUCH worse at around 4mm tread. I'm getting nowhere near the feedback that I had when new and get noticeable drift in the wet. Now at 3mm and they really DO need replacing.
Too early to score accurately, but thought I would post anyway - I bought these tires first, then stumbled across this web site, doh! The Excellence doesn't do well in your reviews and had I have visited this site first, I probably would have bought the F1 Asymmetric. I have used Bridgestone 040 and Michelin Pilot Sport in the past so will be interesting to compare. I will post again when I've done a few more miles.
Which tires do you drive?
Researching the Goodyear Excellence? Rate the tires you actually drive - and help the next buyer choose.
Have had these Goodyear excellence just under a year 13000mls and I think the wear rate is unbelievable (down to wear blocks) and showing up badly when grip is needed on corners when it rains and the suffer from bad tramlining,will not be buying these again and going to try Conti prem contact 2 next
these came with my 57 plate st and did 17000 and wore o.k but i found when cornering it would give me a sense that the sidewall was coming off the rim.it felt very flat but it did grip well in the dry with no tire squeel atall but i now have vredesteins ultrac sessanta and its 100 times better and at a reasonable ?110 a tire inc vat im happy to pay for the performance
These tires are used on police vehicles and are subject to a lot of abuse. I have used them on ST220's, Diesel Mondeos and diesle focus's, and have no real complaints about them. Wet grip is resonable, but as they wear the grip is noticablly less, more so that other tires eg Vredestien Sessanta on my private car. Dry grip is very good and very progessive, which what I value most when driving really rather quickly!
The wear on the diesel Mondeos is highest, but still get 12,000 miles to a set of fronts, even with the abuse they get, and the focuses nearer 20,000, even though they get changed at 3mm.
Generally a very good tire and a lot better in the wet than the old NCT 5's
These tires came on the car when new and the front lasted about 15k miles, although they could have gone slightly longer, if not for a puncture on the front n/s that could not be repaired. The ones on the rear have now done 25k miles and will soon need replacing after 2 years being on the car.
Put Conti Contact 2's on the front at 15k, and found these tires better for grip than the GY's, although they have worn out quicker.
These were fitted to my from standard, and I have to say I think I would be hard pushed to find a worse tire. The main proble is that the sidewall of these tires is very soft. This means Steering feedback and responce suffers. Dry weather grip was so so, but wet weather grip was appalling. If the road is greasy, forget driving your car anywhere, however if it was very wet, they did seem ok.
Possibly fine as a motorway tire, but for any sort of performance use, look elsewhere.
THESE TYRES HAVE ONLY LASTED 11,300 MILES I AM NOT PLEASED WITH THEM THE LAST SET WHERE GOODYEAR NCT 5's AND THEY LASTED ABOUT 28,000 MILES AND PERFORMED JUST AS GOOD I WONT BE BUYING THE NCT EXELLENCE AGAIN !
An improvement over the Dunlop Sport SP01 tires and a MASSIVE improvement over the terrible Pirelli P6000 tires - those things were frightening on bends!
These Goodyear Excellence tires are the finest riding tires I've tried, very quiet with a softness that suits a luxury car. I've not had the car slide at all with these tires (unlike the P6000s).
